Longmire 5.02: “One Good Memory” Episode Review

If the Season 5 premiere of Longmire was a bit slow on the windup, then “One Good Memory” delivers a fastball that wraps up the mystery of the missing Dr. Donna Monaghan (Ally Walker). 

It starts nerve-wracking enough for Walt Longmire (Robert Taylor) as he hurries in the middle of the night to neighboring Cumberland County to see if a reported Jane Doe is the good physician. Have to confess, I was fooled by Walt’s emotive reaction to the woman on the slab, but it turns out not to be Donna, leading him to ask a deputy of Cumberland named Eamonn O’Neill (Josh Cooke) for assistance. You may remember Eamonn from when he subbed in Absaroka County and had a brief roll between the sheets with Vic (Katee Sackhoff).

He agrees to spy on his corrupt boss, Sheriff Wilkins (Tom Wopat), and be on the lookout for Walker Browning (Callum Keith Rennie). It quickly pays off when Walker is located by Eamonn at the Wilkins residence. Walt goes through his standard roughing-up-the-suspects routine, believing afterward, to his satisfaction, that Walker didn’t shoot at him—call it Sheriff’s intuition, I guess. Eamonn’s reward for helping is being fired, and he turns down the offer to work for Walt, sarcastically saying: “Yeah, that sounds great. Leap from one unstable, hostile work environment to another.”

I counted at least seven possible suspects (there’s probably more) that could have abducted Donna, and it comes down to Tamar Smith (Jamie Anne Allman), the ex-soldier with extreme PTSD who thought Walt reminded her of her former commander—which isn’t a good thing because the C.O. had raped her.

The break in the case surfaces when Tamar takes pity on her captive and allows Donna to call her son Andrew (Sterling Beaumon), who realizes the voice message she left him doesn’t sound like his mom’s usual repartee. At the same time, another former soldier with PTSD, Duncan Butler (Mac Brandt), who was also a patient of Donna’s, aggressively goes after a man named Randal (Anthony Horen), who Duncan believes is responsible for her disappearance.

As a veteran myself, I appreciate any show that brings the struggles of our military to a wider audience, but having two in the same story thread was a bit too much. Yes, I get that Dr. Monaghan is working with many battle-scarred troops and that’s part of the plot; still, Duncan was an unnecessary repetitive red herring that added little. 

In another unsatisfactory plot thread, Mathias’s plan to use Henry as his puppet seems to have backfired. Henry says he would rather go to prison than be a pawn, adding that people who have come to admire “Hector” would likely turn on Mathias when the truth gets out. That’s it?! I want more screen time for Mathias, not less. Last season, when it appeared Mathias and Walt were heading toward a cooperative working relationship, I, for one, was looking forward to seeing them teamed together.

At a roadside gas station, Tamar pours gasoline over an attendant who is just trying to help and threatens to light him on fire. Meanwhile, in the restroom, Donna is rushing to leave a message on paper towels. Later, Tamar reproduces that plea for help to a discouraged Donna.

In the proverbial nick of time, Walt’s memory improves, remembering a photo of Tamar by a canoe. With the gas station attendant’s help, he pinpoints a local lake where the two women are holed up.

A showdown occurs—Tamar aims a rifle at Walt and the sheriff levels his firearm at Tamar as Donna looks on. I really liked the handling of this delicate situation. Twenty years ago, in less progressive times, the “hero” would have got the drop on the “crazy,” blasting her away, feeling a bit remorse perhaps, but that’s how it was done to satisfy audiences. Here, Walt is a quick study, understanding Donna as she explains how Tamar thought she was protecting her friend from a possible rape—she’s not a criminal. Seeing Walt and Donna together had brought up repressed memories of being abused by her commanding officer, who Walt resembles, triggering her actions. Walt gives Donna the power by turning the gun over to the psychologist, and Tamar slowly leaves the house. 

How irresponsible for Walt to then walk up behind Tamar on the dock, holding a rifle, after everything that just transpired mere minutes before. She asks to be handcuffed because she doesn’t trust herself and then requests a quiet moment alone. Did you also begin counting down the seconds until the splash? No lawman would walk away given her mental state. A real misstep. Don’t misunderstand, it was a finely acted, highly-charged scene, but it just doesn’t ring true. I’ll chalk it up to Walt being not fully recovered.

See also: Longmire 5.01: “A Fog That Won't Lift” Episode Review


David Cranmer is the publisher and editor of BEAT to a PULP. Latest books from this indie powerhouse include the alternate history novella Leviathan and sci-fi adventure Pale Mars. David lives in New York with his wife and daughter.


  1. Anne Scott

    What station is this on? I used to watch it but now can’t find it – thanks

  2. David Cranmer

    On Netflix. All ten episodes were released at the same time.

  3. Zapp

    Decent but not great, as if the timing (direction, lines) is off a little bit.

    I agree with what you’re saying; having either Donna or the perpetrator end up dead would be a huge cliché.

    I guess Donna is leaving Walt’s life anyway, with her previous life and all.

    What I most look forward to is ep 3 being a “normal” episode; here’s hoping Walt’s stomach wound (or Katee’s limp!) will finally be allowed to heal…

  4. David Cranmer

    Zapp, I found the 3rd episode to be my favorite of the season. Not sure anyone gets time to heal but the 3rd one is a standalone for the most part and I find them the be Longmire’s strong suit. Question: did you find the ending to this episode believeable? That Walt would leave her standing on the dock?

  5. Walker

    VERY late to this party! However, I’ve been enjoying reading your recaps after each episode. Got turned on to this series a few weeks ago and have devoured it! Can’t seem to turn it off after one or two episodes (serious binge watching here…and I even caved and read ahead for one spoiler in particular)…but kinda wish I could slow things up becuase then I could enjoy it that much longer.
    David, I see that Zapp didn’t respond to your question, but I thought I would:
    Walt didn’t exactly walk off the dock and go back in the house. He was standing closeby and talking with his kidnapped GF (don’t like her one bit, btw) so his concern (and distraction) was also for her, and I’m sure he thought Tamar was OK to be allowed that moment of reflection a few yards away from him. Also, he’s a lawman, not a psychologist (though you’d never know it sometimes…in a good way) and not one who knew intimately her struggles though numerous conversations/sessions with her, so I think leaving her alone a few yards away for a few minutes is forgivable for him. As for Donna…well, having been more intimately aware of Tamar’s issues, she should’ve had her eye more on Tamar at that moment…but then again, she’d been through the harrowing situation of being kidnapped. etc. So, I give them both a pass on this.
    I do think it was a quick drowning/death however. Tamar – onscreen – wasn’t under water more than a minute. Doesn’t ring true to me that she couldn’t be revived. However, for the storyline, she wanted relief from her mental demons and the writers gave that to her. I found it believable enough.
    My two cents. 🙂

  6. Patricia

    My comment is a question ? Was she revived or did she die? They have her sitting up and then camera goes to Walt ? I know it takes 60 seconds to drown an adult and 20 seconds for a child .

    • Greg

      I thought the same thing as they had her sitting up, but it didn’t really show her coughing water up so it’s kind of like they left it up to the watcher to decide her fate.

  7. 바카라사이트

    “I didn’t enjoy school as much as I might have, but that was only because I’m happier at home than anywhere else,” he said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *