Exploring the Relationships Between Young Adult and Crime Fiction

Kelley Armstrong is no stranger to Young Adult or Crime Fiction, and Life Is Short and Then You Die—a new anthology that she edited—combines both genres, proving they are not mutually exclusive. Learn more about YA and comment for a chance to win a copy of the anthology!

I’ve been writing young adult fiction since 2008—the height of the Twilight craze—and I often hear new writers being told that certain genres won’t sell in YA. This is particularly true of mystery fiction, and I strongly disagree because the very nature of the teen audience means there is a market for every well-told story.

Watching YA over the years, I’ve been astounded by how open that audience is to different ways of telling a story, particularly in narration and format. First-person narration was the norm in YA before it became widely accepted in adult fiction. Present-tense and second-person narration are still far more common in books for teens. Those readers will also happily pick up graphic and verse novels in a way I don’t see with mainstream adult readers.

The younger the reader, the less concerned they seem to be with “how” a story is told. This first really struck me years ago, when my daughter read a YA novel after I did, and in discussing it, I admitted I found the present-tense jarring until the story swept me away. She said “It’s in present tense? I never even noticed.” I’d noticed it from the first paragraph because, by my age, my brain has come to expect certain conventions in novels, including past-tense narration. When a story varies from that, and I balk. My daughter—having not yet solidified those conventions in her mind—only noticed the story.

I believe the same principle applies to genre. YA saw a huge upswing with Twilight. My daughter was just entering adolescence at the time, and we watched as the single YA shelf in our local bookstore turned into two shelves, and then a whole aisle, and then multiple aisles plus tables as teens latched onto first Harry Potter and then Twilight.

When young adult fiction took off, publishers wanted more of the genre was selling: fantasy. I don’t blame them. The market wanted it, too. I remember signing store stock and watching a woman plunk down over $100 on YA hardcovers. Her daughter loved Twilight so now Mom went to the bookstore and said “give me everything like that, please.” Parents everywhere saw their children finally reading and, to encourage it, they got them “more like that,” from libraries and bookstores.

Read an excerpt of “In Plain Sight” by Y.S. Lee, one of the stories from Life Is Short and Then You Die!

While teens may have wanted “more like that,” I believe their definition of “like that” was often wider than parents and publishers realized. My own vampire-free paranormal young adult found a huge audience, as did fairies, trolls and everything in between. So did teen romances, fantasy, science fiction and more. What they were looking for transcended genre. It was a duplication of experience—I want to feel that way again, swept up in a story.

There has always been a teen market for mystery. I grew up reading Hardy Boys and then transitioning into Lois Duncan. The trick is that mysteries for teens can’t simply be the same book we’d read as adults, but with teenage characters. They require more. Complex relationships, for one. Yes, most successful YA includes a central romance, but that’s just one type of relationship, and teen readers appreciate them all: friends, family, enemies, allies. A mystery may be at the center of the novel, but in YA, it functions mostly as a way of exploring and revealing relationships. They also want the fun stuff: secrets, action, and plenty of twists and turns.

While teen readers may have a favorite genre, they’re usually open to sampling new ones, in hopes of expanding their bookshelf. It’s a matter of focusing on stories that matter to them, and not just trying to capture a popular market by making teen versions of adult fiction. Give teens what they’re looking for, and you can build a loyal readership, whatever the genre.

Life Is Short and Then You Die is the Mystery Writers of America’s first teen anthology, edited by #1 New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong.

Adolescence is a time of “firsts.” First kiss. First love. First loss. First job. The first taste of adult responsibilities, and the first look at an independent life away from both the restrictions and the security of home.

And in this case, a very different type of “first”: murder.

This short story collection of murder mysteries adds a sinister spin to the joy and pain of firsts that have always been a major part of life, whether it be high school cliques who take the term “backstabbing” too seriously, stumbling upon a body on the way home from school, or receiving a Snapchat message that promises something deadly.

Contributors include Barry Lyga, Caleb Roehrig, Emmy Laybourne, Jonathan Maberry, R.L. Stine, Rachel Vincent, Y.S. Lee, Anthony Franze, Barry Lancet, and more!

Comment below for a chance to win a copy of Life Is Short and Then You Die!

To enter, make sure you’re a registered member of the site and simply leave a comment below.

Life Is Short and Then You Die Comment Sweepstakes: NO PURCHASE NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN.  A purchase does not improve your chances of winning.  Sweepstakes open to legal residents of 50 United States, D.C., and Canada (excluding Quebec), who are 18 years or older as of the date of entry.  To enter, complete the “Post a Comment” entry at http://www.criminalelement.com/exploring-the-relationships-between-young-adult-and-crime-fiction/ beginning at 3:30 p.m. Eastern Time (ET) September 5, 2019. Sweepstakes ends at 3:29 p.m. ET September 19, 2019. Void outside the United States and Canada and where prohibited by law. Please see full details and official rules here. Sponsor: Macmillan, 120 Broadway, New York, NY 10010.


  1. Joyce Benzing

    Sounds interesting!

  2. lasvegasnv

    interesting excerpt

  3. John Smith

    Mysteries and fantasies are for everyone!

  4. Christen Jorns

    Really cool idea! I love these two genre’s.

  5. Susan T.

    Teens are a lot more sophisticated than most people give them credit for and the same could be said of YA. I still read a fair bit of YA even though I’m old. Lol!

  6. Kelesea Fidler

    This sounds so cool! Thanks for the chance!

  7. Linda McCutcheon

    What I love as an adult reading YA stories is that they often bring me back to my teen years which I thoroughly enjoyed for the most part. I can’t wait to see where th is anthology of mysteries takes me .

  8. Rena

    My daughter and I are both fans of crime fiction. We’d love to read this.

  9. Megan Kaplan

    I would love to add a YA crime anthology to my classroom library!!

  10. Pam Flynn

    I love the title…It’s something I’ve said all my life.

  11. Tiffany

    Can’t wait for this one

  12. Cheryl Hurst

    Wonderful to see YA adult mysteries returning, I grew up loving mysteries, beginning with Nancy Drew.

  13. Caryl Kane

    Sounds like a page turner!

  14. Diana Hardt

    It sounds like a really interesting book. Thank you for the chance.

  15. Michelle Willms

    This is an outstanding group of contributing authors. I’d love to win this!

  16. Michael Carter

    Sounds great!
    Yes, please enter me in this sweepstakes.
    Thanks —

  17. lasvegasnv


  18. Janet Gould

    Informative article. Sounds like a great book.

  19. Trisha Perry

    This sounds so cool

  20. jennifer c.

    Looks like a great book.

  21. Laurie Sandretto

    Thanks for the article.

  22. Mary Kearney

    I have enjoyed reading some YA books even though I am older.

  23. Amber Sternitzke

    I love YA crime fiction! Can’t wait to read and recommend to other patrons!

  24. Karen Terry

    I love crime stories.

  25. Rebecca Joy Mensinga

    I love short stories! I love horror and thrillers too!

  26. Jeannine

    I would love to read more…YA crime and mystery, something I haven’t thought of since Nancy Drew.

  27. Christal M

    Sounds like a great read

  28. becky Shemeley

    love ya mysteries 🙂

  29. Daniel M

    sounds like a fun one

  30. martin bodnar

    thanks for the chance to win . . . …. ..

Comments are closed.