Book Review: Murder in an Irish Pub by Carlene O’Connor

Murder in an Irish Pub

Carlene O'Connor

Irish Village Mystery Series

February 26, 2019

In Carlene O’Connor’s Murder in an Irish Pub, the cozy village of Kilbane seems like the perfect place for a poker tournament, until the star player is found hanging in the local pub’s broom closet. 

Siobhan O’Sullivan is a Garda in the small village of Kilbane. She’s still pretty new to the job, but she’s a natural. When a poker tournament comes to town, the village welcomes the tourists and players with open arms. All is well until the tournament is called off when the top player is found hanging inside a broom closet at Rory Mack’s pub. Eamon Foley, also known as the Octopus, is the dead man. At first glance it seems as if he has committed suicide, but Siobhan starts realizing that it doesn’t add up. Eamon’s very pregnant widow, along with the other tournament players, and a host of others, all end up as suspects as Siobhan works hard to solve the murder.

This is my first book in the Irish Village Mystery series. I really enjoyed Siobhan’s character as a sure and strong Garda, gifted by her natural inclinations, yet also the softer side she almost lets peek through with her love and boss, Macdara Flannery. I liked their scenes together as much as I did the mystery. The two of them are believable, not over the top, and their forbidden romance adds a little spice to the mix. Also, Macdara respects Siobhan and listens to her, even though he is technically her boss.  Siobhan is part of a large and loving family. She is the older sibling, so they all look to her as a replacement for their parents who have passed away. She is natural in this role and her maternal instincts are strong. She’s a protector and doesn’t have a problem enforcing rules on her younger siblings, but not so that they won’t respect her.

Foley was found with a potential suicide note on him. It read simply, “Can’t beat the Dead Man’s Hand.” This is a cryptic message that plays into the mystery with its explanation.



“Do you know the legend of the Dead Man’s Hand?”


“Yes,” Siobhan said. “Black aces, black eights, and a hole card. Supposedly, it’s the hand Wild Bill Whatever was holding when he was murdered.” Macdara started chuckling. “Bilcock?”


“Hickok,” Macdara said. “America. The Old West. Worked the frontier. Purported wagon master, lawman, gunfighter, gambler, spy-”

Another favorite character of mine was a little explored one—Layla the pigeon. Greg Cunningham cared for a number of local pigeons, but Layla was one of his favorites. Layla begins to return Greg notes from someone that discusses parts of the crime. When one comes back, typed on an old typewriter, Siobhan gets involved. I loved that the pigeon became a part of how Siobhan eventually solves the crime.

He handed Siobhan the note. It was typewritten: THE OCTOPUS HUNG HIMSELF IN FINNEGAN’S.


Finnegan’s. The previous name of the pub. Rory Mack hated when folks still referred to it as Finnegan’s. Whoever sent this note, one thing was for sure, he or she was a local. Siobhan handed it to Macdara. “Your pigeon brought you this note?”


“Layla,” Macdara corrected.


She grimaced. “Layla brought you this note?”


Greg appeared to be growing tired of the humans. “I said so, didn’t I?”


“Where did she get it?”


Greg kissed the pigeon’s head and placed her back in the cubbyhole. She cooed. Siobhan tried not to melt. “Could be from anyone. All the locals know me pigeons. You wouldn’t believe the t’ings people send.” He walked over to another cubbyhole and pulled out a basket filled with tiny little notes.

Murder in an Irish Pub was a delightful read that put me right into the atmosphere and locale. It should also be noted that I was able to pick up this book without having read the prior installments with ease. I didn’t feel like I had missed out on a lot of important information, and author Carlene O’Connor writes it with fluidity so the reader doesn’t have to start at the beginning of the series. That said, I would like to go back and read the other books to see how Siobhan has evolved.

Learn More Or Order A Copy


  1. Markus

    I do not know how Carlene O’connor wrote “Murder in an irish pub ” and make a mystery story! This is how a great observer and writer can make it realistic and true by his own point of view.But this is difficult to express all the stories like and how this moral theme should be implemented in the society.

  2. shawn kemp

    Truly, this article is really one of the very best in the history of articles. I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. And I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go into my collection. Very good work!

  3. susanrichard

    I really like to read this fantastic post! I read your blog and I think it is very informative for all people.Thanks for your great info. And do you want to leave the virtual worth yourself? If you want, let go to the game

  4. muneer ahmed

    The first phase the preparation should, theoretically, be uninfluenced by the intended intensity and duration of the sound which is subsequently produced. In fact, however, so quickly are the three phases accomplished that the pianist rarely has capacity to think, in performance, of each phase separately.

  5. mark spencer

    Surely, we are using development wherever in the urban territories as we use mobile phones generally without fizzle. We use lift rather stairways to go up or down. It’s all occasion by virtue of development. This is an amazing article since you have shared few to a great degree fundamental information about the advancement.

  6. muneer ahmed

    Visit our site to find more about wedding photographer Northern Virginia. We offer engagement and proposal photography in Va.…nvestment-loans/

  7. david joe

    I am searching for some great blog sites for contemplating. I was seeking over web search tools and discovered your blog webpage Well i like your astounding web journal webpage outline in addition to your posting capacities. Continue doing it.Feel free to surf

  8. joli

    I like to read

  9. Wholesale Mens Clothing Suppliers

    thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice blog.

  10. fast and furious 9 tej parker jacket

    Since I read a lot, and love mystery-crime thrillers, I’ve heard a lot about this book. This sounds like quite the thriller that would send chills down your spine. This was already in my to-read list, but after reading your review, it is making its way all to the top of the list!

  11. bestcleaningcompanyindubai

    hey some or most of us are too busy in their lives that they don’t have enough time to clean your homes so we are providing all services of cleaning so that you can feel easy

  12. Nursing Homework Online Services

    I’m really happy I’ve discovered this info. Nowadays bloggers publish just about gossip and net materials and this is really irritating.

  13. Web Design Company Dubai

    Web development is a key to success.If you wanna learn web development then visit Web Design Dubai this will provide you their best.

  14. App Developer dubai

    hey! if anyone is interesting to learn mobile application development or you want the best mobile application development then you must have to visit Dubai App Developer the is the site that can provide you all the services that will be accoroding to your needs. thank you.

  15. resume writing company

    After reading the reviews of this book I am planning to buy this, Actually I am a reader and it is my hobby to collect books and novels. Carlene O’Connor is the best Irish storyteller.

  16. assignment writing

    I’ve loved this series since the first book, and it continues as the series grows. This is the fourth book in the Mystery of the Irish Country, and I look forward to each new book.

  17. Essay Help

    Written a book isn’t easy and written book like on murder that’s enough hard and The hard part of writing a book isn’t getting published I can tell you without hesitation that the hardest part of a writer’s job is sitting down to do the work

  18. Twilight Kristen Stewart Jacket

    Greets! I was checking out your articles for the first time while at work and wanted to drop a line that was very cool. I’d like to share my site too. You can learn about past lives there. Check it out if you’re interested. Thanks really great blog about helping others from your blog.verywell put together. thanks.

  19. Online Assignment

    Written a paperback isn’t easy and inscribed book like on homicide that’s sufficient hard and the firm part of writing a book isn’t receiving available I can tell you without uncertainty that the firmest part of a writer’s job is sedentarily dejected to do the work

  20. women trending Fashion

    Every fashion trend you should know about in 2020. Our experts show you how to wear the latest women trending Fashion for this season and next.

  21. One Piece Washable protective suit

    A very interesting topic that I’ve been looking into, I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. It is wonderful to be here with everyone, I have a lot of knowledge from what you share, to say thank you, the information and knowledge here helps me a lot

  22. Affordable Dissertation UK

    Thanks a lot for sharing this great piece of information.

  23. Cheap dissertation writing services

    A great story which starts in a small village Kilbane. This murder story is very interesting for those people who are in search of suspense.

  24. cipd assignment help

    Don’t be worried about your academic paper because now professional writing services are eager to accomplish the demand of academic writing paper under the shade of expert writers. Moreover, we are fully trained in the field of academic writing that’s why serves our services in different types of writing. Furthermore, we take expertise in the field of dissertation, research paper, assignment, coursework, and essay writing and also provide the best budget to our regular customers.

  25. write thesis

    Do you know that? most of the university students are interested to buy academic writing services because most of the time, they are not fully conscious of the aspects of academic writing that’s why seek professional assistance from its experts.

  26. Lux Makeup Product

    Infused with the finest fragrances, our body washes and beauty bars are set to leave your skin invigorated and moisturized. Explore our Lux Makeup Product now.

  27. Lucia Thomas

    amazing post.

  28. 13 reasons why varsity liberty high jacket

    I read that couple of weeks ago and it has great mystery.

  29. Dora Sussan

    SussanDora is a B2B marketing director at ExportHub. Which is the international b2b importers directory helping small businesses connect internationally.

  30. Assignment Makers In Pakistan

    Hey, I am a student of MBA and I am working as well, So can not have much time to write my assignments. Then I found out about Assignment writing help online, by that service now I am never late for submission of my assignment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *