4 Reasons You Should Read J.D. Robb … According to My Mom

As you may have noticed, we—the reviewers here at Criminal Element—are happily gorging ourselves on J.D. Robb’s In Death series in preparation for the upcoming release of Echoes in Death. But there’s an important voice you need to hear if we’re going to talk seriously about J.D. Robb: my mom’s.   

When you walk into my mom’s house, you go straight into the living room (it’d probably be called a “formal living room” if my mom was a “formal living room” kinda gal … which she isn’t), and the first thing you see is a large entertainment center. You see the normal entertainment center kinda things: television, the entire series of NCIS, and other movies/shows that don’t star Mark Harmon or Michael Weatherly. 

But one thing you will notice very quickly is, along the top shelf of the entertainment center, the entire series of J.D. Robb’s In Death novels on full display—from number one to number whatever-number-J.D. Robb-is-up-to-by-the-time-of-this-writing. (That’s 44 in February once Echoes in Death comes out.)

Okay, I’m exaggerating—only the second half of the series is up there because there’s not quite enough shelf space. The rest is upstairs. And, yes, the series is shelved in order.

My mom LOVES this series. Since she’s read each book more than once, I decided to ask her to share a few reasons why fellow mystery lovers should pick these novels up. Here’s what she had to say.

Characters, Characters, Characters

Mom’s thoughts on the main character Eve Dallas, a homicide detective in 2058 New York: “I got caught up in the character of Eve Dallas. She overcame being abused as a child and became a murder cop to stand up for all the victims in the world.”    

Reading through the series, I found myself agreeing with my mom (who I will not name in this piece because she works with at-risk children herself and I don’t want to compromise anyone’s privacy—suffice it to say that she has quite a bit of empathy for those in pain, whether real or fictional). Dallas is a flawed human being—kinda prickly, definitely bossy, and damaged. But, while some cases hit closer to her past than others, she works through it, growing, adapting, and becoming a true defender for the victims and their families. 

And Dallas isn’t a lone wolf in this scenario either. Her counterpoint, the single-named hero Roarke, is intriguing in his own way. “While Roarke is richer than Bill Gates—not to mention better looking—he, like Eve, is a victim of child abuse. He overcame his past by building an empire and helping others,” says Mom. 

For-Real Flaws

But, don’t think that these heroic characters are interesting because they Save the Day whenever they walk into a room.  

“Dallas has such strength,”—which, I now break in to say, sometimes comes across as bullying-as-defense—“but it’s offset by her fear of children and her absolute compassion for the victims.” 

As far as Roarke, who is borderline too-good-to-be-true in both hotness and money: “He has a refreshing temper that keeps him from being too incredible.”

And together: “The Dallas/Roarke dynamic is one of soulmates who fight, make up, and fight crime and injustice. While they might be soulmates, their love is tested by the fact that they are human. They have to be careful not to cross the line between law and order and Roarke's occasional bending of that line. It’s interesting to watch their relationship change and see that line blur as they grow together.”

A Family of Other Characters

Eve Dallas and her hottie hubby Roarke aren’t the only characters with quirks and fascinating stories. “There are core characters who keep Dallas from becoming too set in her ways and keep her growing as a person.”

You have Feeney: mentor, tech investigator, and friend. According to my mother, “Feeney is the closest thing that Eve has as a father, who saw her potential and trained her to be the kick-butt homicide cop that she’s become.” 

And (my personal favorite) Free-Ager Detective Delia Peabody. “Peabody grew up as a child of the equivalent of hippies but is a rock-solid police officer who grows to be Eve's friend, sister, and partner.”

You’ve got Mavis, the singing/dancing creative best-friend-forever; Dr. Mira, a sharp police psychologist who helps Dallas through personal and professional difficulties; and Charles Monroe, the handsome Licensed Companion who helps “Lieutenant Sugar” (Dallas) navigate several cases.

 “It’s like visiting your best friend and their family with each new book.”

Welcome to the World of Futuristic Crime Fighting

The In Death series is set in 2058–2061 in a New York filled with flying cars, miraculous daily body modification options, legalized prostitution in the form of licensed “companions,” and criminals capable of all kinds of hijinks. 

“The futuristic setting bothered me at first,” Mom tells me, “but I grew used to it. Setting the stories in the future helps promote some of the adventures they get into while solving crimes. It also makes some of the situations they find themselves in more believable.” 

Some of the situations the characters have found themselves in: dealing with a serial killer who targets companions, investigating clone development, holding business meetings on space stations, etc. “The crimes are intriguing, which is helped by the futuristic setting. The crimes vary from drug-related mayhem to crimes against family and friends. I often wonder how she’ll top her last book, and then she does.” 

Check out our review coverage of the entire In Death series!


Jenny Maloney is a reader and writer in Colorado. Her short stories have appeared or are forthcoming in 42 MagazineShimmerSkive, and others. She blogs about writing at Notes from Under Ground. If you like to talk books, reading, publishing, movies, or writing, feel free to follow her on Twitter: @JennyEMaloney.

Read all posts by Jenny Maloney for Criminal Element.


  1. Diana Avino

    Your Mom “hit the nail right on the head”…Although Eve would probably have some great comment about the phrase as she does about so many of them. For those of us who started to read it from the first book in 1995..to those who picked up the books this year…you feel included in this family of characters. Bet there are a lot of us like your Mom who have all the In Death books…NUMBERED…on a shelf in their house somewhere. We bless the day JD Robb made Eve and Roarke walk across these pages for us.

  2. Peggy Perry

    I had seen the J D Robb name on the In Death series but never paid much attention since I didn’t recognize the name and was too busy to pick up on a new series. I’ve also never really been much into ‘police procedurals’. Then one day I saw “Nora Roberts writing as J D Robb” on Naked in Death. I have always been a Nora Roberts fan since my days as a romance fan, so I tried it out and was hooked by page 2. Now I have all 43 books and all the short stories. It is so difficult for an author to combine tears, laughter, suspense, and action in amidst superb dialogue and scene setting, but she does it so well.

  3. Jenny Maloney

    What impresses me is Robb/Roberts ability to turn out such consistently great stories at such speed. And, for my mom’s reading pace…Robb/Roberts is still too slow! Voracious!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *