Whitechapel Episode Three: Jack, Meet Hannibal

Whitechapel cast
The gang’s all here.
The Whitechapel season one finale opened where episode two left off: with Mary Bousfield’s kidney bleeding on DS Miles’s breakfast table. Of course this makes him even grumpier (“My son picked up that parcel!”) and more determined to find the killer. Chandler points out it’s only half a kidney. A note the killer included in the package claims he fried up the other half and ate it, and that “it was very nice.” Well, I was eating fettucine with red sauce while watching this and it was not nice at all. (Spoilers aren’t nice either, unless you’re expecting them—Expect them!)

Chandler declares that the handwriting must be Eastern European—what a talent!—because he’s “done a lot of courses.” Miles gives him a “you’re a weirdo” look but for once, Chandler’s formal schooling comes in handy and makes up for his lack of street experience.

After talking to the owner of the company with the van in which Mary was killed, detectives get the name of the driver for the night in question: Anthony Pricha, who works in the morgue at the hospital. He gets hauled in for an interrogation but says he neither works for the company nor drives a van. Turns out someone stole his identity.

Meanwhile, Chandler lobbies for Buchan to be released from police custody, since the Ripperologist had unwittingly become mentor to the killer by communicating with him and sharing details of the original Ripper killings via Buchan’s website. Chandler believes “Ripper fan” will contact Buchan again before claiming his final victim.

Whitechapel—Pemberton as Buchan
Buchan does his best in this episode.
But Buchan tries to prevent the murder by calling a press conference to say he believes that Mary Kelly, the last victim credited to the Ripper in 1888, was not killed by him at all because of completely different methodology. He dramatically burns his books in his attempt to convince the copycat to stop killing. Of course that doesn’t work, but it does redeem Buchan in my eyes after he interfered with the investigation.

Chandler is certain the killer lives in an area central to the murder sites and goes knocking on doors at a rundown apartment building. He actually runs into his prey but before he can nab him or get a good look (the killer’s wearing a hoodie), Chandler gets slashed and shoved down a flight of stairs. Backup police arrive, they go through the killer’s flat with Chandler, and find all sorts of creepy evidence, including a shrine to the original Ripper, a collection of disguises, and the other half of poor Mary’s kidney. Chandler figures out that it must be Dr. David Cohen, someone they’d spoken to earlier at the hospital about Anthony Pricha, but it’s a tense race against time to find out where and who his victim will be that night.

The unlucky woman is a midwife at the hospital, and it’s a close call for her; police burst into her place as she’s being strangled. Miles gets stabbed in the gut, while Chandler tussles with the killer but the man gets away. This makes Chandler’s superior, Commander Anderson, very unhappy, especially since the tabloids splatter Chandler’s photo on the front page with a headline screaming “Incompetent: The officer who let the ripper [sic] escape.” But Chandler argues, “The 9th of November is over. He doesn’t get another chance to kill a Mary Kelly. He’s failed. Nothing left to live for.” Sure enough, we see Cohen’s body in the river, implying that he committed suicide.

Chandler and Buchan drinking to Mary Kelly in Whitechapel
Drinking on the job
The ending finds Chandler and Buchan drinking to Mary Kelly at her grave, though it looks like they’re drinking from a family-size bottle of Scope.  Then Chandler gets called out to a crime scene, a presumed mugging gone bad. Chandler says maybe that’s what the killer wants them to think. Miles argues that nine of ten times, if it looks like a mugging, it is a mugging. Chandler points out the last time they thought a body was a result of a domestic dispute—referring to the Ripper copycat’s first victim—it wasn’t that at all, and the camera fades out as the detectives are still debating.

It’s a nice ending, seeing as how Chandler and his team seem to have come to a better understanding of how the other thinks. One of the detectives is seen passing out tea to everyone and eating “brain food,” something Chandler had advocated at the beginning to their ridicule. And Chandler seems to have gotten the knack of this detecting business.

But I would have liked to know more about the killer. What motivated him to copy the Ripper? Is he really Eastern European? Why did he jump off a bridge? As Commander Anderson says, “We know nothing about his real identity.” It seems producers wanted to keep the focus on Chandler, and as a fan of Rupert Penry-Jones, I can’t complain about that. I’m also a fan, however, of good crime fiction, which usually includes an antagonist or villain we understand, a true foil for the protagonist, not just someone who exists simply to move along plot points. Because of that, I found the finale lacking, but the suspense factor has been high so I’ll tune in as Whitechapel moves into season two this week with a storyline about killings reminiscent of the Krays’ bloody handiwork.

Will you watch?

Elyse is a freelance writer/editor who likes soup and the Bee Gees, but doesn’t enjoy piña coladas or getting caught in the rain. She also blogs at Pop Culture Nerd and tweets as @popculturenerd and @EditNinja.


  1. Clare 2e

    I’m in with this series, and I like the way the characters have changed. The youngest team member has gotten positivel natty to keep up with Chandler. You’re right, we could’ve used more about how and why the doctor evolved to this. They tried a bit, but I guess that can all end up epilogue, which can be a letdown. I did think the editing was slightly funny during the last climactic scene, because she was being strangled the whole time they were running across town, up the stairs, breaking down doors. . . Still, I also liked how Chandler figured out that David Cohen had been an Eastern European version of John Doe, and a clue in itself. More villains without eyebrows, please, and more Whitechapel!

  2. Carmen Pinzon

    You mean we won’t have to wait for season 2?

    I liked the way our hero lost his political patrons but found his professional peers.

  3. Elyse Dinh-McCrillis

    [b]clare[/b]–Yes, the David Cohen-equals-John Doe clue was quite clever! I like learning new things from my crime fic, assuming that’s really what Eastern Europeans call Jewish John Does. (Though if they don’t know who someone is, how do they know what religion that person practices?) The killer getting his game on in the midwife’s bathroom was creepy, and it did seem as if he was strangling her for a looong time.

    [b]bungluna[/b]—Season 2 starts tomorrow night! I also prefer Chandler becoming a true team leader to his being the commander’s puppet.

  4. https://chinesebuffetnearmenow.net/

    The youngest team member has gotten positivel natty to keep up with Chandler. You’re right, we could’ve used more about how and why the doctor evolved to this.

  5. geometry dash lite

    I enjoyed how our hero lost his political allies but gained the support of his peers in his field.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *