Tom Sawyer, Detective: Twain’s Other Steamboat Adventure

It was always nuts for Tom Sawyer—a mystery was. If you'd lay out a mystery and a pie before me and him, you wouldn't have to say take your choice; it was a thing that would regulate itself. Because in my nature I have always run to pie, whilst in his nature he has always run to mystery. People are made different. And it is the best way.

—Huckleberry Finn

Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn are bored and itching for adventure and why shouldn’t they be after the thrilling chronicles, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer (1876), Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1884), and Tom Sawyer Abroad (1894). In Tom Sawyer, Detective (1896), his Aunt Sally from Arkansas (or, rather, Arkansaw since Mark Twain writes with such charming vernacular perfection) wants him to visit. Tom’s Aunt Sally and Uncle Silas have a neighbor named Brace Dunlap who had wanted to marry their daughter Benny but was told he couldn’t and has since “soured” on the family. They made the mistake of trying to appease Brace by hiring his ne'er-do-well brother, Jubiter, which they can barely afford. Frustrated by these events and deciding they need a diversion that only Tom Sawyer can provide, Aunt Sally asks him to come visit. Huckleberry Finn faithfully tags along, explaining this will cure their spring fever, and he narrates this adventure like the previous classic tales.

Adventure begins on a steamboat down the Mississippi when they meet Jake Dunlap, Jubiter’s long lost twin brother—yes, an incredible stretch of coincidence, for sure—who the family assumed had been killed after a brief criminal career. Turns out Jake and two other thieves stole some diamonds in St. Louis and, at one point, he robbed his two accomplices. Once Jake learns from Tom and Huck that he is considered dead, he plans to make it back to his family’s abode, don a disguise, and blend in as a deaf-mute. Tom and Huck discover Jake’s former accomplices are also on the steamboat and they help Jake escape, but the other criminals are ready for any sudden shenanigans and soon enough are on Jake’s trail again.

Jake had agreed on a rendezvous with the boys but when Tom and Huck arrive they see men enter a wooded area, hear screams, and assume Jake’s been murdered.

We laid down, kind of weak and sick, and listened for more sounds, but didn't hear none for a good while but just our hearts. We was thinking of that awful thing laying yonder in the sycamores, and it seemed like being that close to a ghost, and it give me the cold shudders. The moon come a-swelling up out of the ground, now, powerful big and round and bright, behind a comb of trees, like a face looking through prison bars, and the black shadders and white places begun to creep around, and it was miserable quiet and still and night-breezy and graveyardy and scary. All of a sudden Tom whispers:

“Look!—what's that?”

“Don't!” I says. “Don't take a person by surprise that way. I'm 'most ready to die, anyway, without you doing that.”

“Look, I tell you. It's something coming out of the sycamores.”

Ultimately, they discover the ghost walking about in broad daylight and find the intestinal fortitude to approach the ‘dead man’ who they believe is Jake in disguise. The ghost acts dumb (as they had planned on the steamboat) and Tom and Huck let him go about his business. A more sobering mystery awaits them when Uncle Silas is accused of murdering Jubiter and Tom takes it upon himself to clear his uncle’s good name with Huck’s aid. Of course, all threads are tied together nice and neat by this slim book’s conclusion.

So why has Tom Sawyer: Detective slipped through the cracks of popular reading? Especially since it features two of fiction’s most celebrated creations. Conceivably, because nothing can live up to the Great American Novel—Huckleberry Finn—that preceded it. Ernest Hemingway famously said, “All modern American literature comes from one book by Mark Twain called Huckleberry Finn. American writing comes from that. There was nothing before. There has been nothing as good since.”  No such praise met Tom Sawyer: Detective with the British Guardian’s original review harshly noting, “The whole story is poorly conceived and badly put together.” That’s unfair because the novel taken on its own— and today best viewed as a YA tale—is enjoyable, humorous and allows us another trip downstream with characters that have become like family. Yes, Mark Twain allegedly wrote the book because he needed money and sure the plot owes a little more than just a bit to Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes who, at the time, was just in his first decade of enormous popularity. But, bottom line, if you like Twain, and his Tom and Huck, then you will enjoy Tom Sawyer, Detective. If you don’t go in expecting a socially conscious experience like Adventures of Huckleberry Finn then you will come away with a light, amusing read by America’s foremost storyteller.

A few years after Detective’s release, Twain was accused of plagiarism by Valdemar Thoresen, a Danish schoolmaster, saying the plot was taken from The Vicar of Weilby by Steen Blicher. An article published in The New York Times in 1910 claims Twain's secretary wrote back to Mr. Thoresen in typical Twain fashion, diffusing the situation: “Mr. Clemens is not familiar with Danish and does not read German fluently, and has not read the book you mention, nor any translation or adaptation of it that he is aware of. The matter constituting 'Tom Sawyer, Detective,' is original with Mr. Clemens, who has never been consciously a plagiarist.”

Edward A. Grainger aka David Cranmer is the editor/publisher of the BEAT to a PULP webzine and books and the recent anthology collection, The Lizard’s Ardent Uniform and Other Stories.

Read all of Edward A. Grainger's posts at Criminal Element.



  1. rabbit turkish sex honey in uae

    Order your selection of Sachets & Jars of male enhancement rabbit turkish sex honey in uae that improves sex drive for men and women. Natural Ingredients. Based in Dubai, UAE

  2. Natural stone supplier

    We understand the demands of the industry. That’s why we work tirelessly to ensure you have an efficient and smooth Natural stone supplier

  3. ikea kitchen Builder saskatoon1

    Bridge City is a Reputable Cabinetry & Renovations Contractor. We Provide Services in IKEA Kitchen Design and Construction. We are a Quality Renovation Contractor that Renews and Brings Life back to Existing Properties no Matter what kind of Space you are Looking to Renovate: Bathrooms, Living Rooms, Kitchens, or Other Living Spaces.

  4. Concrete foundation repair edmonton

    Our costs are very low that you can easily affort it. Now there is no need to take out a second mortgage on your home just to afford professional repairs. Our vision is to believe in honesty and giving our customers the best services. Our business is committed to our customers and their needs. Saving you money is part of our solution.

  5. Buy Assignments Online

    AssignmentGlobe offers you the most affordable but excellent custom writing services & assistance by professional qualified writers of USA.

  6. Celebrity B3 orignal shearling jacket

    filmstarlook is the website from where you can get the best leather jackets and new celebrity leather jackets. we make a platfrum from where you can get the best and all the latest celebrity and fashion leather jacket. visit to our store to get the best leather jacket.

  7. Best Italian pizza in al ain

    The food must taste good, giving the pleasure to eat it and must be produced respecting the environment, animal welfare and health The Italian way of eating exalts the genius of a people who pride themselves on artistic self expression in drawing from the assets of a land that is intricately diverse by nature. Human and natural elements have combined in kitchens over time to engender an astonishing verity of dishes.
    That explains why IL FORNO does not represent a national wat of cooking so much as an encyclopedic fund of recipes, techniques and flavors of local inspiration.
    Italian food has triumphed at all levels around the world, in temples of gourmet dining as well as in cafes, pizza parlors, wine bars, fancy food shops, supermarkets and corner groceries. Innovation and respect for the original taste and recipe are the only wat to produce authentic.
    The Company of IL FORNO was born 18 years ago and since that time we are following the same philosophy we brought to Abu Dhabi the highest standard of Italian cuisine.

  8. I really like your content, thanks for sharing more content

  9. Do My College Homework For Me

    If you don’t believe in writing services, we will change your mind! If you tell us specific instructions, our writer will stick to them. Assignmentdoer here and you will receive the best possible paper.

  10. Best Halal Meat Near Me

    Alaqsa Store offers largest variety of Alaqsa Store fresh halal meat near me to your doorstep. Now offering free shipping all over US.

  11. strawberry lipo laser

    Our doctors has a personable and intimate rapport with her patients throughout their inner and outer health journey. She has enjoyed counseling patients and has addressed patients beyond the scope of traditional gynecology. In addition, Our doctors for men in addressing their hormonal imbalances.

  12. Lawyer Near Me

    Who Are the Best Lawyers in area of Philadelphia and New Jersey History? Search Philadelphia Best Lawyers® Best Philadelphia Law Firms rankings for firms near you by using our website search bar.

  13. philadelphia seo digital marketing

    Our headquarter is in Philadelphia, PA. We have a global existence, operating in the USA, UK, Asia, and Australia. We are serving our clients all over the globe. Regardless of different time zones, our team manages to facilitate and collaborate with them to deliver high-quality services.

  14. Williamson Restaurant

    The goal of Williamson Caterers is to meet and exceed our clients’ expectations and make certain that our clients’ enjoy their event as much as their guests.

  15. Best Tire Shop

    We are the leading provider of quality tires and exceptional services in New Castle for 25 years. We have 2 service centers that offer a range of services from an oil change, tire replacement to everything your vehicle needs, and delight our customers.

  16. ralph's philadelphia

    Dr. Ralph’s Automotive Services was established in 1976 by Ralph Sposato and is operated by himself and his son, Franco. Ralph’s passion for cars and automotive technology started at a young age. He was determined to be a great mechanic.

  17. usri yusra novel by husna hussain

    appreciate your efforts, good and nice article.

  18. sudoku 247

    There are many options available to you in your spare time, but will you choose pure entertainment or both entertaining and training yourself? Fun, comfortable, free, and ich are what Sudoku 247 gives you.

  19. smoothie king survey

    That’s a nice article, thank you for a great article. It helped me a lot.

  20. kroger w2

    Hi Guys, I found one website called AllStringNylon where you can find guitars at low cost

  21. shawandme

    I found your web site via Google whilst searching
    for a similar subject, your website came up, it looks good.
    I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

  22. mythr org

    hi nice and appreciate your information.

  23. Air Handling Unit

    Nice writeup!

  24. Appyeet

    This is the best information I ever read on this blog will share the information. Are you searching for the Premium free app, if yes then I recommend read our blog about Appyeet, This is an application that has large numbers of extraordinary premium features. AppYeet provides numerous applications with free premium features. for more info you can visit our site about appyeet.

  25. Minecraft unblocked

    Great article. Did you encounter that site you want to access is getting blocked, and you want to get into it? then you can check our article Minecraft unblocked is generally accessible across various stores, including Mac OS and Windows application stores.

  26. Abogado Accidentes Motocicleta

    Thanks for sharing beautiful content. I got information from your blog. keep sharing

  27. accidente de moto en playa virginia

    I was overjoyed to discover this website. I wanted to say thanks for the fantastic read! Every part of it is undoubtedly enjoyable, and I’ve bookmarked your site to look at new things you post.

Comments are closed.