The Gay Detective: Homosexuality in Crime Fiction

Read this exclusive guest post from Neil S. Plakcy about the history of homosexuality in crime fiction, and then make sure you're signed in and comment below for a chance to win a copy of The Next One Will Kill You!

Before I wrote my first mystery, I read Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, and Erle Stanley Gardner. And before I wrote my first mystery featuring a gay detective, I read Joseph Hansen, Michael Nava, Mark Zubro, and Nathan Aldyne.

Just as Christie, Sayers, and Gardner were among the pioneers of the contemporary mystery, Hansen, Nava, Zubro, and Aldyne were the leaders in incorporating gay characters into crime fiction. Their books opened doors into gay culture at a time when homosexuality was considered a psychiatric disorder and a sure way to break a mother’s heart.

These detectives were able to penetrate closed groups, to empathize with those who were suffering, and to protect those who were unable to present their true selves to society. They had unique insights not available to straight cops (at least not at the time) and often used unorthodox means to bring justice to the afflicted.

FADEOUT by Joseph Hansen
A straight friend—a mystery fiction fan—recommended Joseph Hansen to me. He was one of the very first mainstream authors to write about a gay detective—an insurance investigator named Dave Brandstetter. His first book, Fadeout, came out from Harper and Row in 1970. His wasn’t the first gay detective to hit print—that honor, I believe, belongs to Pharoah Love, a sexy, sassy African-American police detective working in Manhattan, authored by George Baxt. Love was too much a caricature for me, but I guess that was due to the times.

Brandstetter, on the other hand, was a masculine guy and worked for his father’s insurance company investigating claims. From him, I learned about the way that LGBT people stuck together and helped each other out. For example, when Brandstetter needed information from the phone company, he called a lesbian friend. I devoured the books, reading as Brandstetter went through relationships, aged—acted like a regular guy. At the end of the last book in the series, I was heartbroken. I felt like I’d lost a close friend.

My discovery of Hansen opened a new world to me, and next I discovered Michael Nava—a California attorney of Mexican heritage with a strong social conscience. His seven mysteries starring gay Hispanic attorney Henry Rios focus a great deal on the AIDS epidemic and its effect on men, their friends, and their families, and they can be heart breaking. The last in the series, Rag and Bone, shows a novelist at the top of his craft. A family drama pulls Henry in and leads him to some life-changing decisions. I recently read that Nava has a new Henry Rios book coming soon, and I’m looking forward to it.

Mark Zubro also has a strong social conscience, but his books are leavened with humor and a biting sarcasm directed against homophobes and school administrators, among other awful sorts. He alternates between two series, both set in Chicago. Schoolteacher Tom Mason and his lover (and eventual husband), baseball star Scott Carpenter, are amateur sleuths who solve crimes and fight for justice in schools and gay neighborhoods, focusing on community, friendship, and fairness in all things. First in the series was A Simple Suburban Murder, published by St. Martin’s Press in 1989. Tom discovers the body of a colleague in his classroom, and to clear the main suspect, a former student, he and Scott delve into child prostitution and snuff movies.

Zubro’s second series focuses on Paul Turner, an openly gay homicide detective—a rarity at the time of the first book, Sorry Now, published by St. Martin’s in 1991. In that book, the murderers know how to go right for Paul's Achilles heel—his two sons, one of whom has spina bifida. Zubro has said that he created Turner to show another side of gay life: a devoted father whose kids come first.

I feel quite privileged to call Zubro a friend, and even more so to have served as his editor for several of the recent Tom and Scott and Paul Turner mysteries, published by MLR Press. It’s an interesting situation for me because I come to the books as a fan first and editor second.

Zubro was among many great authors of the genre who were published in trade paperback by St. Martin’s Stonewall Inn mysteries, helmed by gay editor Michael Denneny. St. Martin’s was, as far as I know, the first mainstream publisher to set up a gay imprint, with Richard Stevenson, Grant Michaels, and Michael Craft among its stable of authors. It’s probably telling of the mainstreaming of gay culture that St. Martin’s eventually shut the imprint down and shifted those authors it retained into their frontlist.

The fourth author who influenced me was actually two men writing under one name. Michael McDowell, a novelist and screenwriter (Beetlejuice, The Nightmare Before Christmas), and the late Dennis Schuetz wrote four color-coded mysteries under the name Nathan Aldyne: Canary, Slate, Vermilion, and Cobalt. The detective here is Daniel Valentine, a bartender who was once a social worker and still seemed to long for that occupation now and then. His sidekick, a straight woman named Clarisse, starts out as a realtor and then goes to law school, but she continues to hold a torch for Daniel, who is most resolutely gay. The culture of the gay bar is on display here, as well as what it was like to live in Boston in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

Most of these books were already out of print by the time I discovered the genre, and I prowled discount bookstores from New York to San Francisco to Fort Lauderdale to find them. Many came out only in mass market paperbacks, and once they were sold out, they were gone. Others were published in trade paperback editions—and almost none of them made it into public library systems. Today, some have come out as ebooks, but others are available only in used editions.

Many of them, particularly the authors who only wrote one or two titles, have faded away almost completely. Those who are interested in learning more can check out The Gay Male Sleuth in Print and Film by D. Wayne Gunn, an awesome compendium of the field as of the book’s publication date, 2012.

Together, these authors stitched a quilt that reflected the diversity of gay experience. Daniel Valentine and Stevenson’s Don Strachey were both pretty promiscuous—in Strachey’s case at least until he settled down with his boyfriend, former Jesuit Timmy Callahan, whose morals provide a great counterbalance to Don’s “get-it-done” mentality. Tom and Scott are resolutely monogamous and celebrate a gorgeous wedding long before everyone on reality TV was doing so. 

As for me, I want to keep up these traditions, and I think that Angus Green, the openly gay FBI agent at the center of The Next One Will Kill You, is a true descendant of those who have come before him.

Comment below for a chance to win a copy of The Next One Will Kill You by Neil S. Plakcy!

To enter, make sure you're a registered member of the site and simply leave a comment below.

TIP: Since only comments from registered users will be tabulated, if your user name appears in red above your comment—STOP—go log in, then try commenting again. If your user name appears in black above your comment, You’re In!

The Next One Will Kill You Comment Sweepstakes: NO PURCHASE NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN.  A purchase does not improve your chances of winning.  Sweepstakes open to legal residents of 50 United States, D.C., and Canada (excluding Quebec), who are 18 years or older as of the date of entry.  To enter, complete the “Post a Comment” entry at beginning at 3:30 p.m. Eastern Time (ET) November 15, 2016. Sweepstakes ends 2:29 p.m. ET November 22, 2016. Void outside the United States and Canada and where prohibited by law. Please see full details and official rules here. Sponsor: Macmillan, 175 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10010.


To learn more or order a copy, visit:

Buy at iTunes

Buy at Barnes and NobleBuy at Amazon



Neil Plakcy’s fiction has appeared in numerous publications, including Verbsap, Blithe House Quarterly and In The Family, as well as winning first prize in a South Florida magazine contest. He is an assistant professor of English at Broward College and the proud papa of a white golden retriever named Brody.


  1. Gwen Ellington

    Plakcy’s book sounds up all my friends’ alleys!

  2. pearl berger

    A fascinating post and great giveaway.

  3. Laurence Coven

    Should not forget John Morgan Wilson’s Benjamin Justice seriers featuring a gay Hollywood detective. “Simple Justice” won an Edgar. Teriffic novels. Also Jonathan Kellerman’s Psychiatrist series, the shrink’s best friend is a gay LA Detective who appears in virtually all the novels.

  4. zarah

    If you move into the romance genre, there are many gay detectives, but it’s refreshing to see other genres opening up too.

  5. ellie lewis

    Thanks. Most interesting and intriguing.

  6. Karen R

    Very interesting and informative post. Thank you!

  7. Karen Reittinger

    Very informative and interesting post. Thanks!

  8. anne harris

    I recall some of these authors, especially Baxt, who was very broadly characterized. The authors did such a wonderful job creating strong

  9. Richard Derus

    I still want someone in the TV industry to do a wheel of two-hour gay sleuths like Brandstetter, Delafield, Tom and Scott, et alii. *sigh*


    This sounds really great! I love the detective and mystery genre, and learned alot from this post about additional reads for the future.

  11. T

    Sounds like a really interesting read, I’d love to read this book.

  12. John Quiring

    Interesting article. Definitely have to check these books out.

  13. Susan Pertierra

    I like reading FBI mystery/thriller books and this one would put a different slant on things to make it even more interesting.

  14. Peter W. Horton Jr.

    All detectives are interesting! Yes!

  15. Daniel Morrell

    sounds interesting

  16. Crystal Blackburn

    I would love to win the book.

  17. John Smith

    Looks like a fun read!

  18. Patrick Murphy

    Fascinating article

  19. Jean Dickinson

    I look forward to meeting Neil Plakcy’s latest crime fighter Angus Green.

  20. Kat Emerick


  21. Suzanne Rorhus

    I can’t wait to read this!

  22. vicki wurgler

    interesting post-thanks

  23. Andrew Beck

    Ah! To recall the great Joseph Hansen! What a marvelous writer. Not only was he recognized for creating one of the most interesting characters in both gay and mystery fiction, he is also recalled as as one of the writers best able to convey the atmosphere and feeling of Los Angeles, whether it be on a cheerless rainy night with lights reflecting off of every service or on a hot sunny day, as even a ride through the canyons in an air conditioned car can seem oppressive and overwhelming. And, of course, his plots were suitably complicated but honest.

  24. derek

    Than you for this interesting account. I remember discovering Joseph Hansen too.

  25. Yvonne Bressani

    Wonderful, thoughtful post.

  26. Yvonne Bressani

    Wonderful, thoughtful post.

  27. Joan Woods

    Sounds like a very interesting book. Love mysteries. Would love to win.

  28. Deb Philippon

    Really an interesting post. There’s so many mystery writers that I’ve yet to read.

  29. Wilifred Alire

    Would love to read this book, better yet win it!

  30. lasvegasnv


Comments are closed.