Stepping Out of the Shadows: Leslie S. Klinger and Chuck Caruso Talk Edgar Allan Poe

One of the world’s foremost authorities on Sherlock Holmes, Leslie S. Klinger is perhaps best known for The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes. Published by W.W. Norton in 2004, this three-volume project won the 2005 Edgar Award for “Best Critical/Biographical” work. Klinger served as a consultant for the recent films Sherlock Holmes (2009) and Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows (2011), both directed by Guy Ritchie and starring Robert Downey, Jr., as Holmes and Jude Law as Watson.

Klinger’s other important editorial work includes The New Annotated Dracula (Norton 2008), The New Annotated H.P. Lovecraft (Liveright 2014), and a lush four-volume collection of the DC Comics series written by Neil Gaiman, The Annotated Sandman, published sequentially by Vertigo in 2012, 2014, and 2015.

This month, Pegasus Crime publishes In the Shadow of Edgar Allan Poe: Classic Tales of Terror 1816-1914, compiled and edited by Klinger as a follow-up to his previous two collections of neglected Victorian short stories – In the Shadow of Sherlock Holmes (IDW 2011) and In the Shadow of Dracula (IDW 2011).

Poe scholar Chuck Caruso sat down to talk with Leslie Klinger about this new collection, In the Shadow of Edgar Allan Poe.

CHUCK: You’re perhaps best known for your work related to Arthur Conan Doyle and Sherlock Holmes, so what inspired you to turn your attention toward Edgar Allan Poe in this new collection?

LES: I’m pretty widely read in the Victorian age generally, but this is stuff I love and I wanted to share it with other people. When I finished the Annotated Sherlock Holmes in 2005, I realized I wanted to do something else. I’d had so much fun, but I had already written so much about Sherlock Holmes. When I was done, I looked around for a while for a new project until my wife asked me, “What about Dracula?” That was the right question because I realized, wow, I love Dracula and it’s a perfect fit for me because I already have all these books in my library on the Victorian age. Doyle and Bram Stoker are contemporaries, so I like to imagine Holmes meeting Dracula on the streets of London. Once I began my work on Dracula, I started looking back at horror writing from earlier in the 19th century, and that brought me back to Poe. But they’re all so intertwined because Poe’s detective stories are essential reading in order to do anything intelligent about Sherlock Holmes. So I went back and re-read all of Poe’s horror fiction, which I already knew and loved. Then as I got more and more deeply involved in looking at the range of horror writing after Poe, I came to the conclusion there was something important happening that I wanted to share with other people.

But of course in some ways the idea for this new Poe anthology came from two earlier anthologies I edited that have sadly stayed under the radar – In the Shadow of Sherlock Holmes and In the Shadow of Dracula. Those are respectively collections of classic detective stories and classic vampire tales. Both those books are also entirely 19th century material, and they follow the same idea of In the Shadow of Edgar Allan Poe. That is, I wanted to bring to light some of the era’s detective stories and vampire stories that have languished in the shadows of the better-known stories.

CHUCK: Why do you think certain authors, like Poe, have remained so popular over time while others fade into obscurity?

LES: Well, some of it is just luck, but the great boon to Poe was that he was discovered by the academics a long time ago and quite correctly regarded as one of the great American authors of all time. I’m not suggesting that the stories in this new anthology are as good as the body of Poe’s work. Poe set a very high standard and his stories are consistently good. These authors that I see as being in his shadow are not as consistently good. Some of them were quite successful in their day, but their reputations haven’t survived or they’re remembered for other things. Kate Chopin, for example, is best known as a feminist writer but she wrote much more broadly than that. Her story “Desiree’s Baby” was an important one for me to include because it explores the horror that lurks in race for American authors.

CHUCK: Yes, it’s interesting how horror fiction in some ways tends to stay more current than other genres of writing, almost as if these issues that resonate with us on the level of fear are things that never go away. For example, you also include “The Yellow Sign” by Robert W. Chambers who has recently resurfaced in American consciousness because of his influence on the first season of True Detective.

LES: Yes, I felt that I had to include “The Yellow Sign” because it’s so important a story. I’m not sure that people actually read it that much, but it’s become sort of cultish. When True Detective starts riffing on an author that’s pretty impressive. Interestingly, although it’s often called Lovecraftian, it’s very clear that Lovecraft discovered Chambers very late, so he was not influenced by Chambers. He appreciated Chambers, but he did not discover this story until the late 1920’s.

CHUCK: You also recently edited the Annotated H. P. Lovecraft, and Lovecraft was obviously very influenced by Poe. Were you tempted to stretch the scope of this anthology include Lovecraft?

LES: Not really, because I knew I was already doing work with Lovecraft, but also because if this anthology does well I’d like to edit another anthology called In the Shadow of Lovecraft that looks at slightly later horror writers. It would sort of be the sequel to this one and would include people from the 1920’s and 30’s.

It’s funny because Lovecraft helped make some of my selections for In the Shadow of Poe pretty easy. I mention this in my introduction to the anthology, but in Lovecraft’s essay about supernatural literature he picks out a lot of the significant authors who work in the framework established by Poe. These were people I felt I needed to include. Maybe if I do get to make a sequel, In the Shadow of Lovecraft, I’ll be able to print stories by Arthur Machen or Clark Ashton Smith or Robert E. Howard. These are guys who are well known to the Lovecraftians but not on the radar of most readers. I hope to be the career booster for some of these forgotten authors.

CHUCK: This collection includes some fairly well known authors and stories but also some more obscure tales by lesser-known writers. How did you go about selecting these specific stories?

LES: Well, I wanted to go beyond the most anthologized stories and come up with some that maybe would surprise people. Some of these authors are definitely well known. Le Fanu, for example, is well known but not for this story, “An Account of Some Strange Disturbances in Aungier Street.” I had already included “Carmilla” in my vampire anthology, and I wanted to find something less familiar for this book. With M.R. James there were obviously dozens of stories I could have picked, but “Lost Hearts” is one of my favorites.

It also seemed important to expose readers to authors they may not have heard of before. People don’t know his work any more, but F. Marion Crawford is a terrific writer. Another that perhaps is a surprise is Dick Donovan. Donovan was very well known as a mystery writer, or a writer of “mysteries” as they were known at the time. In the Victorian era, there was a lot going on besides the Sherlock Holmes stories. There was also a lot of what we would call now “true crime” – or rather a sort of fictionalized true crime. These were presented as the tales of a New York policeman or the confessions of a London detective.  Donovan was a prolific mystery writer, but he also has this lovely little collection called Tales of Terror, which has got some great stories in it. I have another wonderful story by Donovan in the vampire anthology that comes from his Tales of Terror.

CHUCK: You also include Arthur Conan Doyle’s story “The Leather Funnel” in this collection focused on horror stories. Obviously Poe’s strongest influence on Doyle is through his detective stories that provided the model for Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories, but this collection features one of Doyle’s lesser-known macabre stories.

LES: Yes, it was a pleasure to include Doyle in this anthology because too many people forget that he wrote more than the Sherlock Holmes stories. And the same with Bram Stoker, whose 1914 story “The Squaw” concludes this anthology. Too many people think of him as the author of Dracula and that’s it. These authors with one iconic figure in their writing tend to suffer from ignorance of the rest of their work, and that’s a shame.

CHUCK: For many readers, Henry James is probably best remembered today for his horror masterpiece “The Turn of the Screw,” and yet James disavowed Poe’s influence on his work and even tried to distance himself from “Turn of the Screw” by calling it a “pot-boiler” that he had only written for money. Why do you think some authors have embraced being “in the shadow of Poe” while others have so pointedly rejected him?

LES: Yes, James was almost sorry that he even wrote “The Turn of the Screw.” But Henry James himself is such a well-known author that he wasn’t somebody who I felt I could claim was “in the shadow” of Poe. Doyle and Stoker are both a bit of a stretch in this regard too, but my argument for them is that they aren’t known for this kind of writing. But as to the idea of distancing themselves from Poe, I think some of these successful authors can get very full of themselves. Doyle is a good example of this. He walked around for most of his career saying in effect, “Please excuse me for having written those Sherlock Holmes stories. Now if you’ll excuse me while I get back to my really important work.” But that’s a mistake.

It’s funny because Sherlockians play this game where we ask each other if you could have dinner with Arthur Conan Doyle what would you want to talk to him about. Probably the most frequent answer is that people would want to ask Doyle if he now understands that Holmes is the best thing he ever did. That it really did have value. It wasn’t just that it was popular. It was good.

I think James was the same way. He was a little full of himself and he saw Poe as simply a popular writer because Poe hadn’t yet reached his full level of acceptance as an important author in American literature. He wasn’t yet in the pantheon of great American writers. But Poe was also immensely popular in Europe and I think James may have resented that a little bit because Poe was the other American writer who had already dazzled those European folks. So, I think all of that together is why James and others felt that they didn’t want to be like Poe. They wanted to write “important” work that was going to make people think. They didn’t want to just thrill people.

CHUCK: The anthology ends with “The Squaw” by Bram Stoker. Why end with Stoker and why with that particular story?

LES: Well, there are a couple of different Stoker stories I could have chosen, but Stoker as a whole is not a great writer. He had occasional strokes of genius. Dracula is a lightning bolt of genius, and there are a couple of short stories that are great. “The Judge” is a frequently reprinted story and there are a few others, but mainly it was the timing. I wanted to end this anthology in the early 20th century and Stoker had a couple of very good stories in his Dracula’s Guest collection that came out essentially posthumously in 1914. “The Squaw” is a great story but Stoker is still very much a 19th century writer so he seemed like a really nice high note on which to end.

Comment below for a chance to win a copy of In the Shadow of Edgar Allan Poe edited by Leslie S. Klinger and read some of the very best classic tales of terror!

To enter, make sure you're a registered member of the site and simply leave a comment below.

TIP: Since only comments from registered users will be tabulated, if your user name appears in red above your comment—STOP—go log in, then try commenting again. If your user name appears in black above your comment,You’re In!

In the Shadow of Edgar Allan Poe Comment Sweepstakes: NO PURCHASE NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN.  A purchase does not improve your chances of winning.  Sweepstakes open to legal residents of 50 United States, D.C., and Canada (excluding Quebec), who are 18 years or older as of the date of entry.  To enter, complete the “Post a Comment” entry at beginning at 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time (ET) October 29, 2015. Sweepstakes ends 12:59 p.m. ET November 13, 2015. Void outside the United States and Canada and where prohibited by law. Please see full details and official rules here. Sponsor: Macmillan, 175 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10010.



  1. John Quiring

    Sounds like a great collection.

  2. James P. Pope

    that hp lovecraft essay is great to give heads up to other great writers.

  3. Deb Philippon

    I’ve always liked the dreamlike atmosphere of Poe’s work. Wish me luck in winning!

  4. Gordon Bingham

    Few writeres can acheve the atmosphere of Poe…looking forward to this one!

  5. Gary Thaden

    Sounds like another great Klinger collection of stories we should all read. Thanks Les, for bringing this forward.

  6. Peter W. Horton Jr.

    I dream of winning ! Yes!

  7. Janet Wetzel

    Love these books

  8. Mary Ann Brady

    Would love this. Thx.

  9. Patricia Hill

    Sounds like just the book for my collection

  10. Jeffrey Malis

    Adding this to my TBR list… I appreciate the article and the chance!


    Anything to do w/Edgar Allan Poe is a must read!!

  12. Linda Knowles

    I LOVE anything Edgar Allan Poe, this is a MUST read!

  13. Nancy Marcho

    Love Edgar Allan Poe! Sayeth the Raven never more.

  14. Karen Mikusak

    Would love to win!

  15. Maureen Morra

    love to win

  16. Claire Swainson

    I love Poe! I would love to win this!

  17. Nissa Evans

    Want to win a copy of this book.

  18. Russell Moore

    Poe’s stories, with their dark and brooding tones, introduced my to adult mysteries in my teens. I’ve never lost my taste for them.

  19. Daniel Morrell

    would like to read

  20. keith james

    Thanks as always.

  21. reavab Bennett

    This book looks positively dreamy for a gothic nut like myself. I love Edgar Allan Poe. I would love to win this for my b-day tomorrow!!!

  22. Pam Flynn

    Loving Edgar Allen Poe all my life and this looks like a read I don’t want to miss.

  23. Gary Anderson

    I have read very little of Poe’s work and even that was long ago. I am adding this book to my reading list and look forward to many hours of enjoyment. Thanks for the interview.

  24. Robertedgar Dout

    BIG Poe fan!

  25. Alyson Widen

    Anything related to Lovecraft frightens me. Maybe it should be called Terrorcraft instead.

  26. Kristen Meston

    A few years back I spent an entire year reading everything by Poe. I was surprised by the consistent quality — hardly a dud in the entire set.

  27. jjelizalde

    Poe: My all time favorite author. He was so far ahead of his time in so many ways. He was a brilliant man, not just the melancholy drug addicted writer one hears so often. There were many other facets to him and I’m thrilled to see more written about him.

  28. Kevin McKernan

    Poe both stories and poems. I have his entire collection in my law office

  29. Jeffrey Tretin

    Thank you for the giveaway. Sounds great.

  30. Deanna Stillings


  31. Rick Ollerman

    I wasn’t aware of the whole “Shadow of” books but now I want them all….

  32. MitchellGlavas

    I saw Leslie Klinger at the LA Times Festival of Books last spring, but I didn’t bring my copy of the Annotated Lovecraft for him to sign. I really wish I had.

    Also, it seems that Lost Hearts by MR James is seeing something of a resurgence these days: it’s also featured in Audrey Niffenegger’s Ghostly.

  33. Karen Terry

    I love Edgar Allen Poe. My mom use to have a book with all of Poe’s works that I read when I was younger.

  34. vicki wurgler

    sounds like a great colection

  35. susan beamon

    I have enjoyed Poe and other writers of the nineteenth century, but I still find most of them used too many words. I know it was the style of the time. It has gotten in my way reading more. These collections sound interesting.

  36. Michele Van Epps

    This looks like a fascinating anthology. Would love to add to the public library’s collection

  37. Michelle Schanbacher

    This looks like an amazing collection! I would recommend The House by the Churchyard by Sheridan Le Fanu. I’m happy to see he and M.R. James included in this collection.

  38. Jeanette Barney

    I just checked this book out of the library and I am enjoying the stories very much. I would love to have my own copy.

  39. Diane Pollock

    Sounds awesome!

  40. Joyce Mitchell

    Thanks for the chance to win.

  41. Louis Burklow

    I’m looking forward to seeing how much of Poe’s style these writers took on.

  42. Sharron Walker

    Always intrigued by anything involving Edgar Allan Poe!

  43. Onymous1

    Poe has given us a wealth of ideas and style to look up to and emulate. I hope these writers give us enough chills that we can’t go to bed after reading their tales!

  44. Annie Pott

    Poe has given us a wealth of ideas and style to look up to and emulate. I hope these writers give us enough chills that we can’t go to bed after reading their tales!

  45. Karen Salyer

    I read Kate Chopin’s “Desiree’s Baby” in college. Still recall those final devasting sentences, a worthy inclusion for followers in Poe’s footsteps.

  46. Desmond Warzel

    Count me in, please!

  47. Gwen Stackler

    I’ve never read any of Stoker’s other work…sad.

  48. Saundra K. Warren

    Something new!

  49. Patrice Gottfried

    One of my favorite story tellers.

  50. Jane Schwarz

    Great interview. Thanks for the opportunity to win a copy of this book.

  51. Patricia Boyle

    Edgar Allan Poe is my favorite author, even after all these years. I have a collection of his works and all critical works written about him. I would love a copy of this book.

  52. Andra

    Count me in!!! Would never turn down the chance to read anything to do with Edgar Allan Poe!!! Thanks for the opportunity to win & good luck to all who enter!!!:)

  53. สอบถาม igoal

    Thank you very much for this great post. I am getting a lot of help.

Comments are closed.