Sleuthing out a Solution: Edgar Allan Poe and His Crypto-Mysteries

Join Susan Amper to celebrate Edgar Allan Poe on the 171st Anniversary of his death. Susan posits that some of Poe's most famous works span between gothic, mystery, and crime fiction, AKA crypto-mysteries. Read on for more!

On this, the 171st anniversary of his death, Edgar Allan Poe is more popular than ever and more misunderstood.

Mystery writer S. S. Van Dine describes the detective story as a contest, in which the author seeks to “outwit the reader” by presenting a puzzle that the reader is unable to solve, despite being given the requisite clues. In Poe’s time and before, literary contests very much of this sort were common, particularly in the explained gothic, in which mysterious events of a seemingly supernatural origin are later explained in terms of natural causes. A 1794 review of Ann Radcliffe’s The Mysteries of Udolpho actually described the novel as a “contest,” between “curiosity on one side, and invention on the other.” Radcliffe, suggested the reviewer, “delights in concealing her plan with the most artificial contrivance, and seems to amuse herself with saying, at every turn and doubling of the story, ‘now you think you have me, but I shall take care to disappoint you.’”

Poe himself discussed the contrivances Charles Dickens employed in Barnaby Rudge (a largely forgotten historical novel) to conceal important plot elements. While installments of the novel were still coming, Poe revealed the device by which readers are tricked into believing Barnaby’s father dead. Poe relished such ruses, making them the main focus of his two reviews of the sprawling novel. He noted “how vast a degree of interest” these gave the story, though probably not, he said, to the “merely general reader.”

Given Poe’s appetite for such machinations, for artifice and ruse in general, mystification and quizzing, hoaxing and diddling, amphigory and secret writing, one would expect him to have written tales along very similar lines. And so he did, I believe, over and over in his so-called tales of terror. “Ligeia,” “The Fall of the House of Usher,” “William Wilson,” and “The Black Cat, precisely match the design that Poe described of Barnaby Rudge, in which “every point is so arranged as to perplex the reader, and whet his desire for elucidation.” All contain, too, the same sort of dodges Poe dwelled on in his Barnaby Rudge review. For decades readers have groped through the fog of the narrators’ accounts in these tales. For the most part, the anomalies in their accounts have been explained in terms of the narrators’ incomprehension, intellectual blinders, or self-deception. I see them as stratagems of deliberate concealment.

Let me note, however, a monumental departure Poe made from the explained gothic and the mystery stories that have followed. That is in not providing an explanation in the dénouement. Poe argued in his Barnaby Rudge reviews that such explanations inevitably disappoint the reader, because they can never be as thrilling as the unexplained terrors had been. An author’s dark hints of uncertain evil are only praiseworthy, Poe wrote, “where there is no dénouement whatever—where the reader’s imagination is left to clear up the mystery for itself.” “This,” he adds, “is not the design of Mr. Dickens.” But it surely was Poe’s. His mysteries—his real mysteries, not the C. Auguste Dupin tales—eschew both an explanation and a detective, whose presence alone would instantly alert readers that they are dealing with a crime. Because these tales camouflage the very fact that they are crime stories, I call them crypto-mysteries.

And so might you. Read these tales and see if you don’t find that Edgar Allan Poe was and is the true master of mystery.


  1. John Van Meter

    Please tell Ms. Amper that I can pretty much replace all of her Nancy Drew books, from the vintage dust-jacketed editions to the yellow picture cover editions introduced in 1961. I am a bona fide book seller and not a robot or a kook. Thanks for the conveyance.

  2. Emma Cazabonne

    About Poe, I have just read the most amazing mystery, based on his life and writings. It is a brilliant book, so smartly done, with such a fascinating way of using many of his stories and poems into a plot. The title is The Girl Behind the Wall: Edgar Allan Poe, The Girl, And the Mysterious Raven Murders, written by Bruce Wetterau. To be published on October 21st. Alas, it is self-published and will receive little publicity. It’s worthy of being published by a major publisher as is. I could also see this as a movie! One of my favorite reads of the year – and I do read a lot of mysteries! NB: I do not know personally the author! (alas)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *