Case Closed Podcast Season 3: A Murder in Amish Country

Criminal Element is thrilled to share that the Case Closed podcast from Macmillan Podcasts is back with a new season! For the past two seasons, we’ve shared true crime stories that have been solved, so you always walk away feeling satisfied—no frustrating cliffhangers or ambiguous endings. Now, you can listen to season 3 early on Stitcher Premium! Use the promo code CLOSED to get a free month of unlimited, ad-free access. 

Based off of A Killing in Amish Country by New York Times bestselling crime author Gregg Olsen, this season takes the sensational aspect of true crime to a new level by focusing on a community shrouded in mystery—the Amish.

Thirty-year-old Barbara Weaver was content to live as the Amish had for centuries—with no modern conveniences and as a dutiful wife and mother. But her husband Eli longed for a life beyond horses and buggies, and had a penchant for using a cellphone that he wasn’t supposed to have. When Barbara was found shot dead in her own bed, all eyes turned to Eli…until another player entered the scene of the crime. Who would kill a mother of five, a devout member of the Amish community, and a loyal wife?

Dying to listen? Season 3 will launch on all podcast platforms in Fall 2020 (and we’ll also be sharing weekly episodes and transcripts on our site then), but for now you can start listening on Stitcher Premium at Use promo code CLOSED to get access to weekly, ad-free episodes.

Learn More Or Order A Copy


  1. Thomas Marino

    Thank you

  2. Rosemary Krejsa

    Thank you! Great contest.

  3. ps5 release date

    A very meaningful event, I hope everything will go well

  4. igoal กีฬา

    Thanks for sharing this knowledgeable post. What an excellent post and outstanding article.

  5. Thank you for sharing such a amazing post.

  6. บุหรี่ไฟฟ้า

    Thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward to more post.

Comments are closed.