Book Review: The Midnight Hour by Elly Griffiths

Emma Holmes and her crew of all women PI's face off against her police chief husband and the Brighton police in an effort to find the killer of Verity Malone's dead husband in Elly Griffith's new mystery The Midnight Hour.

Though this was the sixth book in the Brighton Mysteries series, it was very easy for me as a newcomer—albeit one who has enjoyed other Elly Griffiths novels—to jump straight in. It’s 1965, and the intrepid private detectives of the Holmes And Collins Detective Agency have just picked up an intriguing case. The retired entertainment impresario Bert Billington has died, and his youngest son Aaron has rather publicly accused his own mother, Verity Malone, of the crime. While Aaron doesn’t think Verity killed Bert on purpose, he does find the fact that she’s been reading American books on feminism highly suspicious. An exasperated Verity engages Emma Holmes and Sam Collins to find out the truth even before it’s ascertained that Bert was indeed killed with rat poison.

As former policewoman Emma is married to local police chief Edgar, this sets her to the delicate task of using her connections without stepping on the toes of the cops who’ve been tasked with officially investigating Bert’s death. Luckily, Emma’s old friend Detective Inspector Bob Willis has been assigned the case, with the able assistance of Woman Detective Constable Meg Connolly. Emma and Meg quickly bond over their shared interest in detection, as well as their shared experience of being female police officers, even as Emma tries not to let her envy of the younger woman show. She founded the detective agency because respectable married women of the 1960s did not remain on the police force, and especially not with three young children to rear. She can’t help feeling wistful though, and understandably constrained by her role in life:

But this morning she kept thinking about the case. She envied Sam who was interviewing Aaron and then, possibly, [Aaron’s older brother] Seth. It should be me, she thought. I’m the one who used to be a detective. Why wasn’t Edgar supervising the riding lessons? Because he had to work, of course, and his work always trumped everything. The previous superintendent had spent most of his time on the golf course but Edgar was more conscientious. It was one of the things Emma had loved when he was her boss. It seemed far less lovable now, though.

Emma and Sam’s investigations soon lead them to Max Mephisto, former stage magician turned film actor, and a friend to them both. Max is filming a horror movie in Whitby with Seth Billington, the middle child of the three sons Bert and Verity had together. Max is feeling an existential ennui at his change of career, and almost welcomes the distraction. But his involvement with the case will have life-changing repercussions, even as Bert’s killer seemingly strikes again.

This was another terrific fair play mystery that I guessed the solution to right before the culprit was revealed, making me feel as if I too were a detective on the case. I also empathized greatly with Emma and Meg, who are endearing characters forced to make do in a world of rampant misogyny where women’s rights are still very much curtailed. Ms. Griffiths has a gift for both characterization and setting, really bringing her story to life, with appropriate frissons of humor:

Max watched sourly as the sun set behind Whitby Abbey, the shadows turning the arches into portals to another world. Did Whitby have to go around looking so atmospheric all the time? It was like being trapped in a French art film. The ruins, the cliffs, the houses huddled by the shore, the fishing boats in the bar. The whole town felt like a backdrop. And now, as the cameramen exclaimed about the light, Seth came striding through one of the archways, his black cloak billowing out behind him. The Prince of Darkness, brought to you by Savile Row Tailoring.

While there were several loose ends that I felt could have been tied up more securely, overall this was a highly satisfying mystery that skillfully blends actual historical events with fictional but still plausible murders. Most importantly, it doesn’t whitewash the past, frankly depicting how women—and in certain cases men—were forced to cope with limiting stereotypes and, at least in the case of the characters here, rose above them with aplomb.

Listen to an audiobook excerpt of The Midnight Hour by Elly Griffiths!

Learn More Or Order A Copy



    Research has shown that the ideal eating routine is one that is to a great extent plant-based, with a wide assortment of organic products, vegetables, entire grains and fortifying creature items. Superfoods may be a decent section into smart dieting, and understanding the dietary benefit of the food you eat can be edifying, yet there are bunches of good food sources out there to investigate, regardless of whether nobody is referring to them as “super.”

  2. five nights at freddy's

    Thanks for a very interesting review. Your post does not contain clichéd compliments but is based on real feelings. I look forward to reading more.

  3. literature review writing service

    Always a pleasure to dip into an Elly Griffiths book.
    This is the 6th book in the Stephens and Mephisto series by the author. I really enjoy the Ruth Galloway series by this author but have never really felt the same about this series until now. Not really sure why but this book felt so much better than the previous books I had read. As a professional essay writer, it was easy for me to read the book, I like the narrative style The only thing I could possibly put it down to was that a lot of the book featured the two women investigators rather than Max Mephisto who is very prominent in previous books.

  4. شركة عزل اسطح بتبوك

    Great thank you for sharing the amazing article.

  5. write my annotated bibliography for me

    I picked this one writing offerings annotatedbibliographymaker and buyed. It’s completely excellent, i ain’t a seasoned in terms of writing however from the grade I got i’m able to inform those bros did a outstanding job. the guy who wrote it deserves a my love. you can click and purchase essay if you need to have a terrific evaluation.

  6. kingwittechno

    It was a pretty useful piece of information! I’m only getting started with this, but I’m getting a lot more comfortable with it! Thank you, and keep up the fantastic work.

  7. HP Printer Blue Screen Error

    Thanks for sharing this knowledgeable post. What an excellent post and outstanding article. Thanks for your awesome topic . Really I got very valuable information here.

  8. funny food quotes for instagram

    I read that Post and got it fine and informative.

  9. เว็บบอลดีที่สุด

    Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work.

  10. Article

    Thank you so much admin for uploading such amazing content.

  11. famous celebrities

    Thank you very much. Keep your spirit

Comments are closed.