Book Review: The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict

Agatha Christie meets Clue in The Christmas Murder Mystery—a delightful, tense manor house murder mystery from author Alexandra Benedict. Read on for Doreen Sheridan's review!

If you love word puzzles, then you are in for such a treat with Alexandra Benedict’s latest novel! On top of being a wonderfully constructed classic manor house mystery, The Christmas Murder Game is filled with challenges for the discerning reader, imbuing the book with loads of extra puzzling fun. I freely admit to spending far too much time on the anagram game, and am looking forward to tackling the included word search next now that I’m done with the novel itself.

But even if you’re not a word puzzle fan as I am, there’s so much to enjoy in this very modern murder mystery. Our heroine Lily Armitage was raised by her Aunt Liliana after the shocking death of her mother, Liliana’s beloved older sister Mariana. Liliana’s clear bias towards clever, retiring Lily was a constant source of conflict with Liliana’s eldest child Sara. While Lily got along just fine with Sara’s younger brother Gray, Sara’s loathing was so poisonous that Lily moved away from her aunt’s family as soon as she could, keeping up regularly only with Liliana herself.

After her aunt dies, Lily receives a strange letter asking her to fulfill Liliana’s dying wish and return to the manor home of her childhood to participate in the extended family’s annual Christmas Game. As a child, the game had meant twelve days of solving puzzles that led to a large cache of presents on the final day. This time, the grand prize is ownership of Endgame House itself.

Lily is reluctant to return to the place where she last saw her mother, but her deceased aunt dangles a tantalizing offer in front of her. Liliana promises that if Lily can solve the puzzles she’s devised, the truth of Mariana’s death will also be revealed:

Liliana was as soft as the Medjool dates she loved at Christmas. Lily loved them too, although she never forgot the stone inside.


That bit of stone inside her aunt is what summoned Lily here. It’s cruel, when she thinks of it, to ask her to return to this house, with its secrets written on walls and she’s the one who has to strip back the wallpaper. If Liliana had wanted to expose the truth, she could have done so at any time. Why wait till now? Why leave it up to Lily?

These are only a few of the questions that Lily must find the answers to as she readies herself for a difficult reunion with her cousins. In addition to Sara and Gray, the children of her Uncle Edward are also in attendance and vying for the prize. Tom is a counselor and the only single one of his family: his sister Rachel has brought her spouse Holly, as has youngest brother Ronnie with his wife Phillippa. They are all tended to by the housekeeper Mrs. Castle, after the rules are explained to them by Liliana’s solicitor – and Lily’s childhood friend – Isabelle Sterling.

Everything looks like it’ll be your average family inheritance drama until the first corpse shows up. The survivors try to go for help but find themselves trapped in the remote manor house by the heavy Yorkshire snowfall. As the twelve days of Christmas progress and more and more bodies pile up, Lily will have to put her formidable brain to solving not only the puzzles Liliana set for them, but also to unmasking whom at Endgame House is ruthlessly killing off the assembled members of the Armitage family.

I absolutely gobbled up this mystery novel, going back for seconds over segments any time I missed the anagrams in them on my first pass. I was totally immersed in both puzzles and plot, and rate them all highly in terms of being tough but not so difficult as to be frustrating. I was also both pleased and touched by the subplot regarding Lily’s bisexuality, especially by the elucidation of her feelings when being slighted on the subject by one of her relatives:

Lily feels sliced like salmon. She opens her mouth to say all those phrases that come late at night but they are stuck, itching at her throat. She never can say anything whenever someone comments or threatens violence in the street when she’s holding hands with or kissing a woman. Or when she’s with a man and assumed to be straight, leaving her privileged and safer, yet erased. Speaking up is beyond her.

Non-stereotypical bisexuality representation has been a growing and important trend in other genres; it’s nice to see the orientation finally appear in a mystery novel as something more than a plot twist or reason for shame. It adds social depth to an already absorbing mystery and puzzle book that’s the perfect gift for the armchair detective in your life (yourself included!).

Learn More Or Order A Copy


  1. concrete driveway resurfacing

    Great Work. Congratulations to the author. More power.

    • IBD3D

      The game is scary.

  2. flagle

    That sounds exciting. I totally love puzzle and brain games. I may buy this novel.

  3. analytical essay topics

    Congratulations on writing such a lovely article. Your essay is not only helpful but also extremely educational. We appreciate you sharing information with us, but it’s time for us to love you, leave you, and go to an analytical essay topics service so that I can complete my own assignment.

  4. waffle wordle

    Thank you for sharing a very meaningful article, I think it will be very helpful for me and everyone

  5. Dearmer Jacket Cuberpunk 2077

    I have read your excellent post. This is a great job. I have enjoyed reading your post first time. I want to say thanks for this post. Thank you…

  6. leo satellites

    For many markets, providing a global coating of satellite technologies is a modern necessity. The unlimited possibilities and high performance of observation confines make them indispensable assistants in any business.

  7. The issue for some players. An ever increasing number of individuals are utilizing their mobile gadgets to mess around, and it is vital that the games they are playing are viable with their gadgets. There are maybe one or two interesting points with regards to mobile similarity with gambling. The primary thing to consider is the working arrangement of your mobile gadget. There are one or two working frameworks that are famous among mobile gadgets, and not all games are viable with every one of them. The most well known working framework for mobile gadgets is Android, and most games are viable with it. Nonetheless, there are a few games that are just viable with iOS gadgets, so assuming you have an iOS gadget, you will be unable to play the accessible games as a whole.

  8. Roblox

    It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it!

  9. Drift Hunters

    This Drift Hunters is full of energy.

  10. ModTrainers

    With our platform, we offer you the flexibility to tailor your trainer experience to suit your specific needs.

Comments are closed.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.