Book Review: The Hollows by Jess Montgomery

The Hollows

Jess Montgomery

Kinship Mystery Series

January 14, 2020

The Hollows by Jess Montgomery is the second book in the Kinship series, a powerful, big-hearted, and exquisitely written follow-up to her highly acclaimed debut, The Widows.

The Hollows is Jess Montgomery’s second book in the Kinship historical mystery series set in Southern Ohio. The first book in the series, The Widows, introduced readers to Lily Ross, who is appointed sheriff after her husband is killed in the line of duty. Lily is based on Ohio’s first female sheriff, Maude Collins, who was appointed to the position in 1925 after her husband was shot while arresting a man for speeding. The Widows is a gripping read centering on Lily’s struggle with the death of her husband, assuming the role of sheriff, and dealing with local coal mining problems.

Book two picks up a year later when Lily, like her real-life inspiration, has to run her first election campaign to keep her position as sheriff. Her competition is Perry Dyer, a man who believes a woman’s place is in the home. The mystery at the heart of The Hollows is infused with issues of race, gender, and mental health. Montgomery explores how they impact both individual lives and the larger community.

Many of the characters from The Widows are back in The Hollows. Characters that were minor in the first book now take a more prominent role, while those that were major now provide background support. That’s the beauty of having a series based around characters in a small community. Like Louise Penny’s Three Pines series, readers get to know different characters in each book and come to have a deeper understanding of scenes and relationships as the series develops. The Hollows is a strong standalone novel, however, so don’t feel like you have to wait to read The Widows first.

The action of The Hollows opens when Lily is called out to investigate the death of an elderly woman who had fallen from atop a tunnel onto an oncoming train. Or was she pushed? The deceased is dressed in only a nightgown with rags tied on her feet. Finding out who the old lady was and why she died the way she did is Lily’s first priority.

In the midst of this time-consuming investigation, Lily is also worrying about her election and struggling with pressure from her mother and others to maintain her role as a woman in town. She has to remind herself how to be acceptably feminine, which is not an easy task for someone who grew up a tomboy and now works a job that has always been a man’s role. She’s learned to play the “dumb little lady” when necessary to “get more information from men than they intend to give.” But as a woman sheriff in 1920s Appalachia, Lucy faces not only discrimination but outright dismissal. Some even question her sanity.

Lily is also grieving the loss of her husband and feeling guilty for enjoying her job as sheriff, a position she’d never have had without his death. She’s trying to stifle her pain, which makes her short-tempered as she works the investigation and tries to be an attentive mother, daughter, and friend.

One of her friends, Hildy Lee Cooper (a minor character in The Widows), is feeling neglected by Lily and jumps at the chance to help out with the new case. Hildy volunteers to draw a likeness of the dead woman. Her talent and compassion allow her to reconstruct the woman’s damaged face so that those who knew her might come forward after seeing the sketch in the newspaper. As the tension mounts, Hildy takes a huge personal risk to help with the case.

Hildy is also dealing with her own grief and has felt adrift for years. She feels locked in the trap of being the good girl, trying to please everyone. Both Lily and Hildy feel as if they’ve been “hollowed out” by their grief and circumstances. Throughout the novel, Montgomery deftly entwines her characters’ emotional states with the case at hand.

Since her husband’s death, Lily has found that the absences of ordinary, predictable sounds—Daniel shaving in the washroom, Daniel humming, Daniel sitting on the edge of their bed to pull on his boots and then clunking his feet on the floor—are more noticeable than the sounds themselves ever were.


Lily wraps her arms around her midriff, a sudden hollowness roiling her gut.


Perhaps it was like that for the villagers tonight. They were alarmed by the absence of the regular train whistle, the aural ghost of the expected discordant wail, and gathered outside to ask one another what must have happened.

On the other hand, there’s Marvena, a main character in The Widows who takes a more supporting but still important role in The Hollows. Marvena, too, is suffering a loss, but as the immediate trauma has faded for her, she’s made efforts to keep living with love and empathy. She is patient with Lily, and when the two women finally start talking about grief, Marvena offers some words of wisdom:

“Everyone’s different. Still, I can tell you that with Jurgis [her new love], I’ve found comfort … that lets me set aside the pain, now and again. You, though, you just keep hunkering down, waiting for the sorrow to stop, and I understand that. I do. But it’ll never stop, not entirely. You know that. All hunkering down does is give sorrow a way to burrow in, carve a hollow in your heart. Go too deep, and sorrow is all that will ever fill it.”

It’s not only the widows who feel or are hollow. The exploration of emotional hollowness, its origins and expressions, adds layers to this story. Montgomery has written another suspenseful mystery full of atmosphere and surprising historical details. The characters’ emotional struggles don’t overshadow the action but actually help to deepen the historical elements of the story while adding a palpable urgency to the mystery.

Learn More Or Order A Copy


  1. Susan Wilkinson

    Sounded fascinating to look for a deserted town and area. Would like to read The Hollows. Thank you.

    • dark green wool coat is one of the best leading leather jacket store for all the customers who are looking for the best leather jacket quality and design. visit to our website to get thebestleatehr jacket designs 2021 dark green wool coat

  2. Beth Talmage

    After reading about “The Widows” (on Jungle Reds), I immediately ordered a copy. I can’t wait for it to arrive. I’d love to have “The Hollows” waiting for me when I’m done. As a reader I especially appreciate series with strong senses of setting and Kinship seems like such a place. (I’m pretty sure I mangled the grammar in that sentence, but you know what I mean–the place integral to this setting, and that is clear from the get-go.)

  3. enable flash in chrome

    Your article is very useful, the content is great, I have read a lot of articles, but for your article, it left me a deep impression, thank you for sharing.

  4. Eduloh

    Got the book yesterday! Thank you. I appreciate it. Off to read

  5. Pay someone to write my essay

    Hi! I like this website because i have a lot of options to choose and good info.thanks

  6. Love Shayari

    You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

  7. Men'S Faux Leather Jackets

    It’s really a nice and useful piece of information. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us.

  8. Essay Writing Service Uk

    Thank you for posting very useful tips!, An excellent read. I’ll certainly be back.

  9. samsung firmware

    samsung firmware

  10. crack tool


  11. Itsolution24x7

    Customized Shopify App Development Services and Solutions with Effective Usability Metrics by our Shopify experts.

  12. Buy Essay Cheap

    I always like your article because you have provide every time informative post..Thanks!

  13. Best For Channel Amp

    I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed

  14. foundation crack repair edmonton

    Ramma foundation is a company and a foundation that provide crack repair snow remove and gutter clean service. We are the crack repair foundation in Alberta Edmonton. We provide services like crack repair, gutter clean services, show removal, in short we are the foundation repair in Edmonton. If you are worried about the cracks on your home do not worry we are here to get it repair. If you are worried about snow on your roof, we can remove it. We are here to clean you gutter.

  15. Ikea kitchen Builder

    There is no universal rule of thumb to reference while trying to determine when to replace your flooring. This depends on the type of flooring you need to be replaced, the quality of the materials which were used, the quality of the installation process, how you treated the flooring, and so on.

  16. best coffee roastery dubai

    We believe in direct trade or relationship coffees. We believe in not just purchasing coffee from farmers, but cultivating a friendship that adds value, compassion, and integrity to our business as well as that of the supplier and farmer.

  17. natural herbs for male enhancement

    Mr. Tony noticed the market is filled with many low-standard Epimedyum brands that produce multiple unwanted side-effects. So he felt inspired to create a safe and luxurious Epimedyum product.

  18. coffee beans abu dhabi

    here is why, let me break it down for you. This urban street café and barbershop (yes, I said barbershop) offers a modern design with an industrial twist giving you a Scandinavian style to sit, sip, and chill at best cafe abu dhabi .

  19. Electrical lighting Abu Dhabi

    Our manufacturers and suppliers are known for their quality, creativity, and technical excellence in home automation dubai

  20. order essays reviews

    If you are a student, you may need from time to time the help of expert writers. To choose the best writing service, you can rely on reviews.

  21. Arabic Calligraphy in Dubai

    We have been offering high quality Arabic Calligraphy in Dubai, we have high resolution Canvas Printing & Wall Art Printing in Dubai that can be stars of your wall.

  22. New year 2021 wishes

    Thanks for shairng great post bro, can you share more info please

  23. best happy wishes

    This article is an appealing wealth of informative data that is interesting and well-written.

  24. Charly Wiliamse

    I have thought so many times of entering the blogging world as I love reading them. I think I finally have the courage to give it a try. Thank you so much for all of the ideas!

  25. womens leather jackets

    instylejackets makes you stay classy and suave! We have a stock of all standard sizes, as they’re available for people of all ages.

  26. happy mothers day sister

    i really like your content,thank for nice post

  27. custom essay writing service

    We want to make strong relation with our customers and that’s why we always try to provide better assistance and guidance. Our prices are not as high as our target customer is students and we know better the financial condition of a student.

  28. Cosmetics free shipping coupon

    Such an amazing deal and offer come on guys buy what ever you want with discount 50% upto 90% soo what are you waiting for??

  29. rabbit turkish sex honey in uae

    Order your selection of Sachets & Jars of male enhancement rabbit turkish sex honey in uae that improves sex drive for men and women. Natural Ingredients. Based in Dubai, UAE

  30. SOIL MODIFICATION services in USA

    Often, the subgrade soil is too wet and can’t provide the strength and support to the overlying pavement. In other words, soil that exceed the optimum moisture content is unworkable, making it impossible to meet the requirements for structural earthworks. For more visit to our website

  31. edmonton eye exam

    Our comprehensive eye care services include glaucoma management, pre- and post- operative cataracts care, pre- and post- LASIK, diabetic eye disease co-management, corneal disorders, and more. Routine eye examinations are important to maintain good eye health, as many vision problems are symptomless, but are diagnosed easily by an Optometrist. By diagnosing eye and vision conditions early on, we are able to provide treatment options, and in many cases maintain, restore, or prevent vision loss.

  32. Pizza Ovens Edmonton

    Get your professionally installed envious design pizza oven today in Edmonton, Alberta. Contact us to get more information on the best solution to construct and install your very own custom design pizza oven.

  33. PVA Deal

    We are expert in making all type of Phone Verified Accounts, You can order us custom PVA accounts also and get good PVA Deal, We deliver almost all accounts in few minutes, 24/7 Live Chat support available, As well as email support also.

  34. Best Agency for SEO in Pakistan

    If you wish to get the best SEO Services in Karachi, you should choose the Best Agency for SEO in Pakistan that has ample experience and reputation in this sector.

  35. rehann rehann

    good post like it

  36. Anna Richard

    Great book, enjoyed reading it!

  37. Paytowriteessays

    Thanks for your review! I always read book reviews and then decide if I want to read the full book or not.

  38. order essay online

    books are men’s best friend indeed , you guys are doing great job.

  39. Panel paintingservices in abu dhabi

    We pride ourselves on our body and paint service; we always strive for quality and perfection. At ALSA Automotive, we know that when it comes to the bodywork of a vehicle, this job must work and treat with the highest possible quality. After all, it is the most visible part of the car and must be flawless.

  40. Paytowriteessays

    Adore this book!

  41. muuduu furniture coupon code

    I am glad that I am using this site. This is very helpful site. If you want to save your money then visit here. For further details click the link.

  42. Mhj Consultants

    MHJ Consultants is pleased to provide Contracting and Consultancy services for property management for renting, buying, selling, renovation, refurbishment, new design & construction, and contracting

  43. Take My Class Cheap

    Much obliged for another fantastic article. What other place may just anyone get that sort of data in a particularly ideal method for composing?

  44. Yaro

    Cool book! Recently I was surprised that none of my friends read it, I will send them your review.

  45. Swed Techs

    Great article…
    I think it’s great story book

  46. Inthemarket

    That’s an amazing review.

  47. Flotilla IOT

    Flotilla IoT white label GPS tracking system is a complete telematics solutions with personalized branding. It is designed ideally for companies that want to make their brand identity in the market. The best part about the Flotilla IoT white label system is that it not only offers excellent features but also has a lot of customized branding options.

  48. Careerokay

    Presently, thousands of jobs are available undersection jobs in Karachi and jobs in Lahore area in Top Private Sectors like IT, Marketing, Retail, Insurance, Media, Journalism, Finance, Advertising, Manufacturing, Construction and more.

  49. Best Coffee Capsules

    The Coffee Souq, your new source for everything coffee. We’re dedicated to giving the UAE a whole new coffee experience by offering the widest range of products, from capsules to machines, instant coffee to coffee merchandise, and so much more!

  50. Flotilla IoT

    Fleet management software is a growing need in the telematics industry. Different logistics and delivery businesses deploy smart management solutions to run their operations smoothly.

  51. la datcha cabo

    Salmon Bruschettas, Antipasto, Prosciutto With Melon, Caprese Salad With Italian Buffalo Mozzarella, Marsala-style Veal Scallopini, Fresh Hand-made Ravioli Florentine-style, Penne A La Vodka, Tiramisu Cake la datcha cabo

  52. Electric Longboard

    We provides you with best quality E Board, electric longboard for sale and electric skateboards. Get the best Motorized Skateboard at the cheapest prices.

  53. PDF Remediation Services

    Acadecraft hires professional who identify and fix accessibility issues. We are specialized in providing PDF Remediation Services. We have the capacity to produce high volume Doc remediation capacity to fast transform digital assets, and reach compliance.

  54. Car washing auto zone Dubai

    To protect your vehicle against corrosion our unique car rust proofing formula that does more than just cover the metal is required. Our top quality rust proofing material is applied as a high-pressured spray, ensuring protection to your vehicle’s most critical areas by penetrating, displacing existing moisture and protecting the many vulnerable crevices of your automobile.

  55. Car Brake Services Abu Dhabi

    The brake system is an extremely important safety feature on your vehicle. At ALSA Automotive Repair, we understand that a brake system is essential for your safety and that of other drivers. Our experts will examine the entire brake system, including the pads / shoes, hydraulic fluids, rotor and drum wear, calipers and wheel cylinders, brake hardware, hoses and pipes, master cylinder and the anti-lock braking system for your car.
    Car Brake Services Abu Dhabi

  56. best online gift shopping

    Then again, there’s Marvena, a principle character in The Widows who takes a more supporting yet significant job in The Hollows. Marvena, as well, is experiencing a misfortune, however as the prompt injury has blurred for her, she’s put forth attempts to continue to live with adoration and sympathy. She shows restraint toward Lily, and when the two ladies at last beginning discussing distress, Marvena offers a few useful tidbits:

  57. Lady Shake Discount Code

    The Lady Shake was created to help women maintain their well-being so that they can take care of all their family members. Use Lady Shake Discount Code if you want to buy a Lady Shake at a discounted price.

  58. Gracie Mathew

    My habit is to read the review of the book first and then to decide whether to read the entire book or not. Thanks for the amazing review. Really loved the book.

  59. DazzDeals Coupon

    I think this is what I was looking for, really hard to find like wordle unlimited wordle. I haven’t been able to find it appearing in any of the articles. Thanks very much. If you need to find coupons for brands when shopping, you can click here

  60. Maverick Top Gun 2 Jacket

    Shop this best Super quality Maverick Top Gun 2 Jacket

  61. DCD Garage Floors

    Hi, I do think this is an excellent web site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I am going to come back once again since i have saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide other people.

  62. sspcoatinggarageflooring

    That is a good tip particularly to those fresh to the blogosphere. Short but very precise info? Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article!


    Great web site you have got here.. It?s difficult to find high-quality writing like yours these days. I honestly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  64. coatingsnwcomplete

    I absolutely love your blog.. Excellent colors & theme. Did you build this amazing site yourself? Please reply back as I?m attempting to create my own site and would like to learn where you got this from or what the theme is named. Thanks!

  65. The blue Collection

    Hello there! I just would like to offer you a big thumbs up for the excellent information you’ve got right here on this post. I’ll be returning to your site for more soon.

  66. Urbanmatter

    I read this book on vocation, it was ok. Not the best out there!

  67. order essays

    Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. Really helpful.

  68. cabelas black Friday

    Step up your shopping game for the biggest extravaganza of the year. The black Friday sale of 2022 is closer and we can smell some deep discounts on your favorite products. This year with the ongoing inflation and crisis you can find your favorite store Cabelas Black Friday Deals to put up some of the biggest discounts you have ever seen.

  69. Nursing writing services

    This is an amazing site

  70. Nursing thesis writing services

    Are you searching for nursing thesis writing services? We are the best solution for you

  71. jpost

    We can help you to find the best writing services

  72. Rossi Decorative Concrete & Epoxy

    Good content, great points, very well written. Good job all around!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.