Discount: <i>Someone to Watch Over Me</i> by Yrsa Sigurdardottir Discount: Someone to Watch Over Me by Yrsa Sigurdardottir Crime HQ Get a digital copy for only $2.99! Review: <i>Light It Up</i> by Nick Petrie Review: Light It Up by Nick Petrie Angie Barry Read Angie Barry's review! Jody Gehrman Excerpt: <i>Watch Me</i> Jody Gehrman Excerpt: Watch Me Jody Gehrman A gripping psychological thriller exploring intense obsession and illicit attraction. Review: <i>Jack Waters</i> by Scott Adlerberg Review: Jack Waters by Scott Adlerberg David Cranmer Read David Cranmer's review!
From The Blog
January 18, 2018
Crime Fiction Hall of Fame: David Goodis
Brian Greene
January 16, 2018
Q&A with Christopher Reich, Author of The Take
Christopher Reich and John Valeri
January 12, 2018
Man Steals Tank, Crashes through Store Window, Steals Bottle of Wine
Adam Wagner
January 9, 2018
Q&A with C. J. Tudor, Author of The Chalk Man
C. J. Tudor and John Valeri
January 8, 2018
Q&A with Aimee Hix, Author of What Doesn’t Kill You
Aimee Hix and John Valeri
Showing posts by: Michael D. Cicchini click to see Michael D. Cicchini's profile
Thu
Apr 6 2017 11:00am

Steven Avery and the Criminal Justice Machinery

Making a Murderer made a compelling case that Steven Avery was actually innocent of the Teresa Halbach murder. And Avery’s guilt or innocence is still a topic of debate—at least in some circles. For example, Ken Kratz and Peter Wilkinson wrote a book that promises to prove, once and for all, that Avery is guilty.

But this debate about factual guilt or innocence badly misses the point. In my new book Convicting Avery: The Bizarre Laws and Broken System behind Making a Murderer, I demonstrate how Avery’s conviction is unreliable due to the deeply flawed rules and procedures that were used to obtain it. 

For example, Wisconsin’s ethics rules allowed Kratz to try the case in the media long before the real trial began. Viewers of the documentary will remember Kratz describing Avery—in vivid detail—as the deranged, “full of sweat” uncle who raped Halbach before murdering her. As juror questionnaires later revealed, this pretrial media blitz erased the presumption of innocence and put Avery in a deep hole before his trial even started. 

[Read more about the trial laws that doomed Avery from the start...]