Thu
Apr 10 2014 3:15pm

Pierce Brosnan’s Ventures West: Grey Owl and Seraphim Falls

Like Sean Connery (whose Western films I recently reviewed), Pierce Brosnan is known predominantly for playing James Bond and other suave roles that capitalize on his handsome looks coupled with effortless charm. And, like Connery, besides being a solid actor, he has delved into Westerns sparingly with just two forays that deserve mentioning, both with less than boffo box office results. That’s a shame because Brosnan is adept at playing gritty, hardened characters.

In Seraphim Falls, Gideon (Brosnan) is being hunted by Carver (Liam Neeson) near Ruby Falls circa 1886. He's been wounded, nearly drowns, after a harrowing plunge over a waterfall, and must use a knife and spare bullets to start a fire before he succumbs to hypothermia. You can feel the desperation as he fumbles with the ammunition to stay alive. An edge of your seat opening with Brosnan's taut acting, among the best of his career, alone make it worth the view.

This heart-pounding action then morphs into the back story where we discover that Gideon is an ex-Union captain who has traveled west to escape a brutal past while Carver is a former Confederate, who, for very personal reasons, can't let go of what happened during the war. The back-and-forth and one-upmanship between these two foes reminds me a little of Lee Marvin and Toshiro Mifune in Hell in the Pacific, except in the John Boorman film, you have a sense that Marvin and Mifune may reach a common ground whereas in Falls there is no sense that closure is in the cards for Gideon and Carver.

Brosnan is equally balanced with Liam Neeson who is one of the great thespians of our time, his characters burn with the sheer consuming intensity that he injects to each performance. In Falls, the part could have easily been a one-dimensional, man-hunter type throwaway, but Neeson delivers an in-depth characterization of the conflicted Carver. Neeson says he was steeped in Western mythology growing up compared his character, Carver, to Captain Ahab in Moby-Dick, “he's totally governed by this idea of revenge where he’s practically lost his humanity.”

Maybe it’s because I’ve always appreciated man-against-nature films like Jeremiah Johnson and Cast Away that I recall this 2006 revenge Western film a little more fondly than other reviewers. Example: Los Angeles Times gave a mixed review stating that it ran out of ”gas during an overlong allegorical final section."I don’t agree and my only gripe is the flashback that propels the retaliation storyline is stagy and the emotional tug they were going after stops short. Oddly, I found this crucial scene where Carver’s family perishes to be as close as you can come to observing the rough draft of a story before any prose layers have been added for depth. But that didn’t stop me from enjoying the film, Seraphim Falls is a thought-provoking Western with swift action, fine acting, and a moral story that sticks with you long after the final scene.

Somehow, the life of Archibald Belaney (September 18, 1888 – April 13, 1938), aka Grey Owl, had escaped me until I watched Richard Attenborough’s 1999 film starring Brosnan in the title role. The story opens toward the end of Belaney’s life with a reporter discovering the believed to be Native American Grey Owl was in fact the British born Belaney, who chides the journalist, “What took you so long?”

From there the film jumps back to pivotal moments in Grey Owl’s life: his conversion from well-to-do European to self-sufficient Indian, then from the life of trapper to a conservationist, and the people who had an impact on him along the way (the most influential being Anahareo).

When Grey Owl meets Gertrude Bernard (played by the lovely Annie Galipeau), also called Anahareo and Pony, she wants him to be her guide through the mountains. He leaves without her, but being a determined woman, she finds a guide to escort her to Owl’s cabin. In a dramatic scene, as she is following Owl across an ice-covered lake, she doesn’t follow his advice and plunges into the freezing waters. He rescues her, they eventually fall in love, and remain together for a number of years. Over this time, she convinces Owl to change his harsh trapping ways (after raising two motherless baby beavers and growing very attached to them) and he converts to a conservationist. He came to believe that “the trap, the rifle, and poison” would someday result in “the Dwellers in the forest to come to an end too.” Because of his popular tour guides, a wealthy publisher—aware that he’s tapped into a goldmine—approaches the charismatic Grey Owl to pen a biography, which he accomplishes with Anahareo’s encouragement.

As a boy, Attenborough met the real Belaney and it’s obvious the iconic figure had left a positive impression on the future academy award-winning director who created this heartfelt biopic. Brosnan thoroughly immerses himself in the role and his brooding depiction of Belaney made me forget that at one time he played the wise-cracking, charismatic thief in the television series Remington Steele.

Seraphim Falls and Grey Owl are minor films in the genre but both are highly entertaining, due in no small part to the talent behind them and none deserve more recognition than Pierce Brosnan with his committed, multi-faceted portrayals. Makes me hope he heads down some wild trails again.


Edward A. Grainger, aka David Cranmer, is the author of the Cash Laramie and Gideon Miles series and recently edited BEAT to a PULP: Trails of the Wild.

Read all posts by Edward A. Granger for Criminal Element.

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
Individual - You will receive an alert for each comment added to this post.
Digest - You will receive an end-of-day alert for all comments added to this post.
12 comments
1. Mates
Wow, Brosnan in Westerns, that I did not know existed. He does look good roughed up a bit and out of his suits and slick hair. These sound like great Sunday afternoon movies. You have peaked my interest, once again great review.
Edward A. Grainger
2. EdwardAGrainger
Mates, Brosnan reminds me quite a bit of another Hollywood star and that's Brad Pitt. Once the 'pretty boy' status faded away from these two, they showed filmgoers what a few of us already knew: they are damn fine actors.
Brian Greene
3. BrianGreene
These are both news to me and both look worthwhile based on your words here, David. On my list.
Edward A. Grainger
4. EdwardAGrainger
Glad to add to your burgeoning list, Brian. Since you have added heavily to mine. :)
5. Kayla Knapp
I have never really been one for westerns, but each time I read one of your articles I find myself becoming more and more intrigued by this gunslinging world. Great Job :)
Edward A. Grainger
6. EdwardAGrainger
Ha. My goal is to convert as many souls as possible. Wait. That sounds weird. Nevermind. But thanks for stopping by, Kayla.
7. Kevin Casey
Liam Neeson and Pierce Brosnan together? Now that's something I've gotta check out. Great article David!
Edward A. Grainger
8. EdwardAGrainger
They work well together and, hopefully, will again. Thanks for taking the time to read my article, Kevin. Appreciated.
Terrie Farley Moran
9. Terrie
I had no idea. I would never have thought of Pierce Brosnan in a western. Thanks for the eye opener. And Kevin is right--Neeson and Brosnan together--should be extraordinary.
Edward A. Grainger
10. EdwardAGrainger
Terrie, Pierce Brosnan reminds me a bit of Tyrone Power who was in the Western Jesse James (1939) but was, perhaps, better known for matinee good looks and swashbucklers. Though, like Power, Brosnan has acted in quite a number of genres, from drama to light comedy.
11. randal120
Grey Owl, I'm unfamiliar with, but Seraphim Falls was one I enjoed.
Edward A. Grainger
12. EdwardAGrainger
randal120, I hadn't heard of the film either until I was surfing from one thing to another on YouTube and ran across it.
Post a comment