Wed
Aug 14 2013 5:00pm

The Rhyme and the Crime: Lizzie Borden’s Forty Whacks

Lizzie BordenLizzie Borden had an axe
She gave her mother 40 whacks
When she saw what she had done
She gave her father 41

 

Do you remember that rhyme from childhood? A friend recently brought it up to a group of us and it just rolled off my tongue.  I didn’t even have to think about it.  But as we started talking about the rhyme none of us knew how much of this short deadly poem is true. So we decided to do a little research on those murders that took place 121 years ago this month, in 1892.

Andrew and Abby Borden were in fact brutally killed that hot August day at their home in Fall River, Massachusetts, but did Lizzie Borden kill them?  The facts may surprise you.

Who Actually Died?

Andrew Jackson Borden and Abby Durfee Gray Borden, Lizzie's Father and StepmotherThe body of Lizzie Borden’s father, wealthy banker Andrew Borden, was found hacked to death in the parlor of the Borden home. When police arrived on the scene and went upstairs the body of Andrew’s second wife, Lizzie’s stepmother, Abby was discovered.  The coroner at the time confirmed that Abby was killed before Andrew, so our poet got the timeline right, but Abby was Lizzie’s stepmother not her mother. They didn’t have such a great relationship, which is one of the reasons Lizzie landed on the suspect list so quickly. Lizzie and her sister, Emma, thought their stepmother was only after their father’s money. Emma was out of town when the murders went down and was never suspected.

Why Was Lizzie Borden the Only Suspect?

Police became suspicious when Lizzie burned the dress she wore that day. In 1892, it was likely that she only had a few dresses, and clothing was more expensive than it is today relative to income. So why did she burn that dress? She claimed it had been stained by paint. The officers on the scene thought it might be stained with something else entirely.

The police also thought it was strange that Lizzie didn’t seem upset after the murders. It was noted in the police report that she did not faint. When you combine that with Lizzie’s disdain for her stepmother and the fact that, as spinsters at the time, Lizzie and Emma replied on their father’s money, and he was notoriously stingy, the police had found their suspect and they weren’t letting go.  

Was the Murder Weapon Really an Axe?

Lizzie Borden's AxeNo. It was a hatchet, but the word “axe” rhymes better with “whacks”.  This grisly method of murder, in combination with the accusations against Lizzie who was 32, made this a mega-sensational trial. At this time, women were thought to be the weaker sex and rarely murderers. Lizzie with an axe in hand made a great story for the newspapers.

How Many Blows Did it Take?

While both Bordens died from blows from the hatchet, it took considerably fewer whacks than claimed in the poem. The coroner said it took 19 blows to kill Abby Borden and only 10 or 11 for Andrew. He also said that both Bordens were dead after the first blow. The other blows were unnecessary. It shows the killer was raging mad when the couple was murdered and possibly had personal reasons to be so angry.

How Much Time Did Lizzie Borden Spend in Jail?

None.

She was acquitted of the crimes. And the jury only deliberated for ten minutes before reaching the Not Guilty verdict.

Lizzie Borden's JuryLizzie lived out the rest of her long life in Fall River, Massachusetts, where many of her neighbors still believed she was guilty. She and her sister, Emma, had a falling out in later life, but the reasons for their strain are not clear. Lizzie and Emma inherited their father’s estate in equal parts and were able to live as rich women.  

The crime has never been solved and no one else was ever charged with the crimes.

If you want to learn more about Lizzie Borden and her family, you can visit the old Borden house, now the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast and Museum in Fall River, Mass.  Their motto?

Where everyone is treated like family.

 

The owners are serious about the bed and breakfast part of the title, you can spend the night, host a wedding or a “paranormal experience” at the Borden House.

The Borden House

The website features the Lizzie Borden community, where each year members can win a night at the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast. The gift shop at the museum is full of 40 whacks kitsch ranging from the Lizzie Borden bobble head to murder scene coffee cups and an axe cookie cutter.  Lizzie reportedly still haunts the property.

 


Deborah Lacy also writes over at Mystery Playground. You can find her on Twitter @quippy.

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
Individual - You will receive an alert for each comment added to this post.
Digest - You will receive an end-of-day alert for all comments added to this post.
2 comments
Terrie Farley Moran
1. Terrie
We used to jump rope to the Lizzie Borden song. I have always been fascinated by the case. Did not know about the B&B. Very tempting for a night of adventure . . .
Deborah Lacy
2. DeborahLacy
@terrie - It is a fascinating case. We never jumped rope to it thought. That sounds like the beginning of a book...
Post a comment